Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Photos on Catalina - Places and Memories

I've recently upgraded to Catalina on a MacBook Pro 13" (2016) and am using Photo's for the first time. I've imported approx 6,000 pictures (and approx 200 videos). All appear to have been imported correctly, however they are not displaying on the map when you select the 'Places' within the library. When I check the individual images they have GPS tag information (approx 5,000 have GPS data, 1,000 are older images or scans without). When I look at individual image and scroll down on the image it display on the map correctly.


Also, the 'Memories' option within the library only has 6 'Memories', I would have expected many more. When I select a memory and then scroll down within the photos for that memory, there is a 'Related' section that has related 'Memories' that seem much more reflective of what I would expect to be show in the 'Memories' option in the Library.


I've tried importing the same images onto another MBP (slightly older but also on Catalina) and have similar results (no places and very few memories).


These libraries are not synced to iCloud.


Any ideas on how to resolve the issue.

15 replies

Hi WayneE71,


I have the same problem you described. On previous MacOS versions 'Places' was all correct. I found out that it only happened when the photos are not included in the album (referenced files).


I hope there will be a solution soon as I want to keep all my files in it's own directory structure.

homie2go wrote:

Why to consolidate? If the software supports referenced model in its settings it must simply support it.

Consolidating is currently the only hope to get the Places feature to work. If the missing Places pins do not really bother you, you could wait for a bug fix.

I stopped using a referenced library, when I switched from Aperture to Photos, because the support for a referenced library is so poor in Photos. There is no tool at all, to relocate referenced originals to a different volume, if we need to move them, when a volume starts failing. There is no support to reconnect originals, if we have to restore a library from a backup. For a large Photos Library it would take a very long time to reconnect the broken originals one-by-one. It is a disaster waiting to happen.


Instead of a referenced library I am simply keeping copies of the originals on my archive drive, in addition to my Photos Library, where I can readily access them.


I too have the same problem. Photos Version 5.0 (121.17.170). Catalina 10.15.2. 80000 externally referenced photos (mixed raw, JPEG and HEIC) on external SSD volume where I also keep the 200GB library. On Mojave everything worked great. Now Places will not display a single photo. Also - on Mojave Photos somehow picked up GPS location info from the associated XMP files (which were in the same directory) during import and now it does not. Also all editing history on all photos lost during the library update. What a mess.

The referenced photos are the problem. The Places map is fine, as long as you consolidate the photos into the library.


You could move the Photos Library to the same volume as your referenced files and consolidate them there.

Is or has the Thunderbolt storage drive been used for Time Machine? That's also a no-no.

I am also having this problem. I have a very large library of all referenced files (due to the large number of photos). In previous versions of Photos, places worked fine, but it is not working since upgrading to Catalina. I am also having issues with referenced live photos and being able to edit them. It seems like this version of Photos doesn't work well with referenced files and I'm hoping for an update to fix this soon. I know engineering is aware of the live photo editing problem and I'll do some more research before calling support about the places.

I know that it's referenced files that are the problem. But, due to space limitations, I cannot have a consolidated library as I have almost 2TB of photos that I reference from Photos. There has never been a problem with referenced photos before Catalina. It seems like Catalina broke so many things that worked well before.

Why to consolidate? If the software supports referenced model in its settings it must simply support it. The developers messed big time here. Many many many people have their images repository structured in directories of their choosing having available for various non-destructive software. With this blunder Apple developers just put another dent in trustworthiness to place tens of thousands irreplaceable memories in their hands.

Equally feeling frustrated. Our 50,000 odd photos sit on a NAS drive. I like the idea of personal control over how my photos are saved. My biggest consideration is... Where will I & Photos be in say 20yrs time? In my mind, I want all the original files easily accessible and organised for whatever the future presents. I don't want all my photos bound up in an application (consolidated) that can't then be immediately extracted in some sort of structure order.

Now that Catalina has broken the references (and clearly I'm not alone on this one), I'm really ticked off as Photos has now become, in effect, unusable.

FWIW, I have copied the entire top-level folder containing all our images, and the Photos Library, to a Thunderbolt attached storage. Relinking here just hangs Photos.

After consolidating 70 000 images into the photos library I can see places again. However, I can’t edit and adjust most of RAW images which were edited previously. Even when I choose revert to original and do edits again. Photos says ‘can’t load/save adjustments, please try again later’. It seems like previously unadjusted raw files can be edited. And it also seems problem is in white balance adjustment. What a mess came with Catalina.

Where are the photos located that you reference?


What model Mac do you have?


Nope never. But I'll take it one step further... the drive (Lacie 2Big) has just been freshly formatted (Raid 1 - Mirror, APFS). My photo files and the Library are the only thing on it.

My fingers are crossed - to the point of being bound together - that a 10.15.3 update has something towards a fix in it.

Hi WayneE71,


It sounds like you're having some trouble with Photos and I want to help.


You'll want to make sure both Photos and Maps have access to the internet and a known good internet connection.


Do you have any firewall or security software that could be interfering with either app's ability to connect to the internet?


How long has it been since these files have been imported? A large amount of data being imported can take a while to index, and you would want to leave the Photos app open while it has time to complete that task.


You can also try rebuilding the library as seen here:

How to use the Photos library repair tool - Apple Support


Again, be sure to leave the Photos app open for a while while this completes.


Let me know if that helps.


Thanks for using the Apple Support Communities.