Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

“Person” smart albums no longer work correctly in Photos 5.0

I use Lightroom (and previously Aperture) to edit my photos and add metadata before exporting the final versions to Photos. I identify people (“face names”) before exporting and the final photos include “People” keywords. I then add “face names” in Photos if the app didn’t add them automatically (or incorrectly). I used smart albums (in Photos 4 and earlier) to assist with the process of adding “face names” for selected people. I would create the smart albums follows:


Keyword - is: “Ralph”

Person - does not include: “Ralph”


This allowed me to quickly identify any photos that were missing the “Ralph” face name and add the “face names” very quickly to each photo.


In Photos 5, this function appears to be broken. Most (but not all!) photos of “Ralph” will appear in this smart album, despite that the “face name” is correctly identified in the photo. Oddly, I have created smart albums with a “reverse” check to find photos where “Ralph” was added in error and these albums seem to work properly. For example:


Keyword - is not: Ralph

Person - includes: Ralph


This correctly identifies photos where the “Ralph” face name is incorrectly labeled (i.e. there is no “Ralph” keyword).


Anyone no what is going on? Possibly these smart albums are working “correctly,” but just differently than previous versions?

8 replies

I already filed a bug report for this. I suspect it is not a bug, but an inconvenient new feature.


My smart album "Match All: 'Person is Léonie' and 'Person is not Léonie'" is empty in Photos 4.0 on Mojave but has many photos in Photos 5.0 on Catalina macOS 10,15.2. It is showing all photos, where I am together with another person, that is not myself.

What seems to have changed, that "Person is not xy" is true for any photo, that has some person in the photo, that is not named "xy". It does not matter, that "xy" is in the photo too. The semantics of "Person is not" has changed in Catalina, not for the better.



I am using a similar keywords approach to save the names of the named people. The keywords will usually survive the system upgrades, but the named faces not.


my work-around for this new problem is to create an additional standard album "Person:xy". I add all photos from the Person album xy to this new standard album.

Then I can test "keyword is xy" and "album is not xy".


But I have to be careful to remove all photos from the xy album, before I delete it because of this new Catalina bug: https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-250001966


Please send this to Apple. I agree with everything that you write. I am in the process of implementing keywords for all identified faces. It is a lot of work (because it is only useful to me if I also create smart albums that make use of the keywords), but in the long run it will be well worth it. I am not convinced that Apple listens to customer's opinions, but if you don't try then there is zero chance of influencing Apple.

You are way ahead of me! Yes, I also sent this issue to Apple earlier today.


I was also wondering if Apple did this intentionally... although the benefit is not obvious to me. However, the semantics of the instructions are incorrect for the "new" result (Person - does not include: “Ralph”). To be more correct for the "new" result, it should be: Person - is not: “Ralph” (i.e. I would still consider this a bug given the semantics of the instruction). At the very least, it is a nearly useless "feature."


Thanks for the workaround... I will give it a try, but it seems this may become more of a hassle than it's worth! Thankfully Photos still supports keywords! Hopefully Apple won't eventually decide they are to "complex" for their consumer software!


Thanks again!

Thankfully Photos still supports keywords! Hopefully Apple won't eventually decide they are to "complex" for their consumer software!

I hope so too!

This is a draft of an additional feedback I want to submit, don't feel forced to read it all.


I am very concerned about the future of the keywords, because after nearly five years of Photos they have still not made it to Photos iOS or iPadOS: Even the iPad Pro Max can still not show the keywords or titles for a photo. It is incredible. Perhaps this will change, now that we have a separate iPadOS. The artificial intelligence of photos can add some thematic information to our photos automatically, but it does not know the history of a photo, why we took the photo, or what the photo means to us. It can recognise object categories, but not yet recognize all special events. We need keyword to structure our library thematically according to categories, that Photos cannot recognize.


The keywords are currently the safest way to name people. It is worth the effort to add the keyword with the names to preserve the work we invested in naming people. Initially I started to add the names as keywords in Aperture, so I could embed the names into the original image files. This helped a lot, when I migrated the Aperture Libraries to Photos.

And I kept it up in Photos, because of the many advantages of names as keywords.

  • Thanks to the keywords I can see the names of the people in the Info. Without the keywords I would only see a tiny thumbnail of the face, that will not tell me what the person is called. I am adding names to the faces to be able to look up the name of a person. II do not ned the People album to tag persons I know well - I need it to remember the names of people I have only met a few times. It is so clumsy to have to open the People album to look up the name. Even with "View > Show Face names" enabled I cannot see all face names below the faces circle including the last name, because Photos will show many names just as a short name, without the last name, if the person is in the Contacts. The people album will also only show the start name in the title. I have to search in theContacts to find the full name.
  • The early versions of Photos did not sync the named faces with iCloud Photos, but all versions are syncing the keywords. The keyword saved me from having to name the same faces over and over again on three Macs, an iPhone, an iPod touch, and iPad.
  • The face recognition is occasionally tagging the faces incorrectly or even merging two people. If this happens, we can use the keywords (and the smart albums you mentioned) to detect and fix the wrong names.
  • After a major upgrade of Photos, when the face recognition algorithm has been updated as well, we may have to confirm or name many faces again. Having the names saved in metadata files, that can survive a changed face detection algorithms the keywords will help to get this done consistently and faster than having to do it from scratch. Worse, the information, what a person is called may be lost completely, if it has not been saved in the title, keywords, or description and we have forgotten the the name. Sometimes it is just hard to remember the name of a person, we have only met a few times and not seen in a long time. So the keywords are our safety line and backup of the faces names, when Photos is discarding the face information.
  • Keywords are embedded, when we export a photo, so we can transfer them and archive them with backup copies.

In short - keywords are man essential to organise my Photos Library reliably, thematically and personally, in addition to the automatic structure created by Photos. The information stored in other library items, like albums and folders, people albums, places albums, is occasionally lost or changed during a library upgrade or iCloud syncing or when migrating to another DAM.


Thanks for the additional info on using the smart albums with people. Helpful!


I agree 100% with your feedback on Keywords. I can easily see Apple dropping keywords altogether. Your observation about their lack of support in iOS isn't encouraging.


I only use smart albums linked to keywords for my photo galleries and this is the reason I don't use iCloud Photos. None of my photo galleries would show up on iOS! After years of using Aperture (and now Lightroom) I doubt if I will ever use Photos as my primary photo processing tool. It would be too risky to hope they won't "dumb it down" and drop critical features. I was originally hopeful that they would gradually improve its' functionality, but I'm not so sure at this point. I haven't completely given up hope, but it seems they are going the wrong direction (for my usage, anyway).



I consider your comments here as things that "obviously" need to be supported. Too bad Apple does not see things this way. I wish there was someone who used Photos and had influence in Apple that we could petition for changes.

Thank you for your comments, Jeffrey and David. I'll file the feedback on the keywords as a feature request (Detailed and Effective Bug Reporting - Apple Community).


For Mac users the Photos.app on iOS is an upside-down world. It is giving priority to the tasks we do not need on the iPhone because they are better supported on a Mac and can wait, till we get home, but for the features we really would enjoy to have on the iPhone or iPad, immediately after taking a photo, there is no support in Photos. We can adjust the photos on the iPhone, but usually I prefer t 00004000 o wait with adjustments, until I can see the photos enlarged on a large display. But what I would like to do on the iPhone or iPad, right after taking the photo is to add a title and a description, when I still remember why and how I took the photo. Or tag the photos on my iPhone or iPad with titles and keywords on a long distant flight home. The lack of support for custom Metadata on my iPhone and iPad it forcing me to always take a MacBook Pro with me on vacation. The iPad Pro Max does not suffice. I can see the photos beautifully on its large display, I can even do some edits, like straighten them or correct the perspective, but I need to use third party extensions to add a title or rating, keywords and descriptions, which is too complicated to do, because it requires to much interaction. Some metadata need to be added at once and cannot wait, for example the circumstances, when we took the photo. If someone asked me to take a particular photo for them, I would like to add this information, or when we are doing field experiments, I need to add the information about the experimental set-up the moment the photo has been taken.