Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Ventura Behavior Changed: Photos Upload Dialog - Can't See Folders and Albums, only the entire Library.

When I attempt to upload photos to Smugmug via its Web interface, I click "browse this computer" and a Finder-ish dialog pops up. Prior to Ventura, when I click on "Photos" under "Media" in the left side pane, it would bring up a new pane that had at the top, the Apple Photos color-wheel icon, with a dropdown that showed my Apple Photos Folder and Album structure. I could navigate to a Photos Folder / Album, select the photos from that album I wanted and they would upload. Now in Ventura, the behavior changed. In Ventura when I click "browse this computer" on the same Smugmug interface, the Finder-ish dialog pop-up still shows "Photos" under "Media", but I do not have the option of navigating through my Apple Photos Folders and Albums. I only see a view equivalent to Library / Photos in Apple Photos. There is a blue folder saying Photos at the top, no color-wheel, and no Folder/Album structure, and no way to navigate to a particular Album in Apple Photos. I want to see the Folder / Album information so I can easily find the photos I have already organized into albums and not have to pick through my entire library. I have tried Safari and Chrome with the same result. How can this functionality be restored in Ventura?

42 replies

I was told by Apple today it's not going to be "fixed", that they have purposely removed it. They had me fill in a request asking to consider reinstating it. For those of us running businesses this is crazy. Saving them to a file or sharing still does not fix as it won't allow to set the order of the photos. I am searching for an app to add.

I would suggest your information is correct. I spent over an hour on the phone with apple a while back. It took getting to a supervisor but she was clear they had removed it. She said it was causing a huge backlash and that people should file a request feature report (not a bug report ). And that possibly with enough feedback Apple would reinstate it. So there is reason to continue to discuss it and encourage people to report. And people are asking if anyone found a work around, not fix the problem. I am replying to both of the last posts and there was no reason for Yer_man to reply in that manner. Let's be civil or silent.

Some applications are still showing the list of albums in the photo picker (Media > Photos) in Ventura, for example Mail or Pages, but I also cannot get the sidebar with the albums to show in Safari or any other web browser any longer, and neither in Preview. You may want to send feedback to Apple with a bug report: Feedback - Photos - Apple


to find a photo to upload in Safari I am currently using the search field, when the photo picker appears. I open the Photos.app to look up the filename of the image I want o upload, then enter the filename in the search field in the photo picker to find the image.


Until then a workaround is in order. What I do is add a unique keyword to the photos I want to upload and then search for the keyword in the browser's Media window:



Uncle is on the right. The other two images are mules, i.e. every keyword is assigned to them.

I don't think it's going to be fixed. I'm currently in Madison WI and yesterday, I took my MacBook Pro into Graphite, which is an Apple Authorized Service Provider. The Technical Specialist thought he could help me but after going into the back to discuss it with some of the other techs and checking with Apple Support, he came back to say Apple deemed it a security issue and decided to disable the application. Apparently, Apple has decided that all of us with our photos are running the risk of having our photos stolen/used and the company did not want to be hauled into court.


I find it despicable that they have crippled their millions of Mac owners without ever giving us the opportunity to opt out of updating to Ventura because they were worried about losing money over a security issue and wanted to cover their collective butts.


Yes, you could drag and drop, you could rename all of your files...but I ask you, how much TIME and ENERGY do you have to do that?? I know I don't. I've always sung the praises of Apple but I am disgusted by their disingenuous screw job and if and when I have to replace my current laptop, I doubt I'll buy another Apple product.

Yes, that seems to be the case. Tell Apple about the problem via Feedback - Photos - Apple



If enough of us report it it will get bumped up to the top of the fixit list.


In the meantime you be able to find photos that you want to upload name the title to something you can search for easily in the Upload window.


I contacted Apple about this issue a couple days ago. Their conclusion was that I use the drop and drag feature. I have a business. I do not want to rifle through thousands of photos to up load ? number of photos. Wasn't the whole purpose of sorting and categorizing Photos into folders to make them accessible. It's almost like having a new program -- say FreeForm -- that is pretty much useless on a iMac.




Just did the Ventura 13.2 update. Still not fixed. My work-around is to export everything in a given Album to a Folder, then upload from that folder. What a pain! Apple, please fix this. (I just sent another request via the Feedback link shared above by @Old Toad)

This is totally ridiculous, since they’ve basically taken away from Ventura users the way that Photos also works on iPhones and iPads. It had worked pretty much the same on all platforms until now.


And use drag and drop? I had to admit that I hadn’t thought of that, and while it does work, it either requires a lot of screen real estate or for you to drag the Photos window way down in order for you to drag the particular photo into the right place in the other app.


What a pain.


And yes…searching for the filename of the photo or photos works if you can remember them. Hmm…I guess the trick here is that when you create an album to name the photos with a prefix that indicates the album they’re in. Then when you search for them you can find them easily.


Again…what a pain!

@Richard.Taylor: No, you can't "just search on the album name". But, I could be wrong, please explain.


In Ventura, on whatever site I am trying to upload to I click "Browse Computer" (or equivalent) then get Apple's pop-up window. (At any time, typing an Album name in the upper-right search box yields nothing ... whether "This Mac" or "Pictures" is selected for the Search option). On the left bar, clicking "Photos" under "Media" brings up the thousands of pictures in my library, but no option to view the Folders and Albums that my photos have been carefully organized into. "Search" seems to look at Filenames, Keywords, Places, Named faces etc. but NOT the Album names or Folder Names where I have organized my photos.


On my old Mac-Mini that can't be upgraded beyond Catalina, no problem. The albums are all visible when I click Media/Photos. Easy. It does what a computer is supposed to do, make things efficient.


So, the Mac-Mini stays on my desk and Apple loses out on a sale of a new system specifically because of this behavior. OK, now we are talking about the bottom line Apple, listening yet?


Those of you recommending sending Apple "Feature Requests" etc., please re-post the URL(s) where you recommend doing this.


As a work-around to this supposed security risk, It would be helpful if Apple would implement a feature to "Add Album Name to Keyword" for all photos inside that album. Click once, done - no copy/paste errors etc. But this is still extra work compared to how things work in Catalina.


Thanks.

Feedback - iMac - Apple

This link takes you a drop down box for Feature requests. I have the exact same issues as you. I even tried adding keywords yesterday on a file and that was not successful for me. Extremely frustrating


Searching for keywords is working very well for me - perhaps Spotlight has not yet finished the indexing of your keywords.

Viewing the "Media > Photos" view in the File chooser dialog, entering a keyword will find the photos with this keyword.



But since yesterday, after I installed a security update, there are new glitches. Unless I open Photos, before I try to click "Media > Photos", I cannot even open the media Browser. And frequently the search field is dead and does not allow to enter a query at all. I have to restart Photos and the app using the Media Browser frequently.


Well, it's a workaround until Apple fixes it. In the meantime let Apple know about the problem frequently (if you can) via Feedback - Photos - Apple



Agree....I do not recognize the photos app with Ventura 13.2 upgrade on my new iMac. Files and folder are organized in a way there is no drag and drop flow. Menu is over-engineered. Slideshows are closed to most user editing.


iMac 5K 27in 2020


Same thing here. I'd like to begin work on a Snapfish photo album but it's exhausting to go through my entire Photos. Has this been resolved by Apple and if so, what should I do? Thanks for any help someone can give me. I'm really sorry I updated to Ventura. What a crappy 'update' ~ APPLE, are you listening??

Is there such a thing as a photo app with Ventura 13.2 that only works on an iPhone? If so, that's nuts for a lot of reasons. I'm 75 and in the beginning stages of macular degeneration ~ having to use a phone to work with photos is just impossibly difficult! I need those larger files to see and work with!! I'm sure I'm not the only person using a MacBook Pro who is challenged. Apple, I'm soooo disappointed in your lack of concern for all of your users.

That would be wonderful! I'm not a business but I feel for those owners who were blind-sided by Apple's obvious mistake. I'm simply a person who uses my Photos a lot as both my husband and I create books for our grandkids as well as for ourselves. I'm hoping this gets resolved fast so I can finally do our 50th Anniversary book before March 10! Yes, I could probably do drag and drop but OMG I am 75, with the beginning stages of macular degeneration and I hate wasting all that time and energy when it was originally a perfect (for the most part) application. Thank you for this information, Old Toad!

Thanks for this reasonable work-around. I haven't bought a replacement computer - still using my Mac mini that can't be updated past Ventura, but doesn't suffer this limitation. Photo selection in albums just works, and saves me time by avoiding extra steps in my work flow.

That's completely absurd. I have a business too, so need the same functionality as you. I've send feedback. But even if I didn't have a feedback can you think of a single other platform where you can't see photos sorted? Madness, makes it so difficult to use

What an idiotic move by the developers. Not only is it impossible now to access individual folders within the main photos directory; the sorting options, e.g., name, date added, list, icons, etc., which remained in place don't seem to work either. I fail to see the rhyme or reason behind this change to the platform.

Yesterday, I saw a message saying there was an update to Ventura. Happy Dance...but it didn't happen. My Photos has not improved. I'm left wondering what the heck did they 'improve' with the so-called update. I'm so bummed. BIG disappointment in Apple.

There are two ways to add a keyword to a photo:


1 - select the photo(s) and bring up it's Info pane (⌘_i). Then type in the keyword you want to use in the Keyword field.


2 - select the photo(s) and type ⌘+k to bring up the Keyword pane. If the keyword is already in the list select it. If it isn't then click on the "+" button at the bottom and add the keyword you want to use. Then close the edit and select the keyword.

Imagine having 12000 photos... all neatly categorized in albums. Product photos (I have a business), family photos, vacation photos. And now having to go back and add key words to them... as if I had time... This is insanity!


If YOU have a solution to our collective problem with PHOTOS, please share it. This is NOT Facebook or twitter, a place where many feel comfortable deriding others. Post a solution, please. I'd appreciate it as I'm ure, others here would too.

I was just trying to clarify, not deride. You make a pretty large claim there:


I don't think it's going to be fixed. ... Apple deemed it a security issue and decided to disable the application.


If what you say is true, then there is no solution. And the folks on here suggesting you file a bug report (which they do in good faith) are wasting their time and yours too. As Apple have not said anything publicly, and you seem to have extra information, I thought it worth clarifying your source so that we might evaluate the rather large claim you're making.


So, I think I'm quite entitled to ask is your source:


the guy went in back and talked to the other guy, who claimed to have talked to Apple Support, who told him things they've told nobody else.


Or do you have some other inside track no one else is privy too. No need to get defensive or offended, just answer the question.


And if you actually believe what you write, that Apple have deliberately disabled the application, then why are you demanding that I or anybody else provide a solution when none is possible, as Apple have disabled the application. I'm just trying to understand.

Keith Gatling wrote:
I guess the trick here is that when you create an album to name the photos with a prefix that indicates the album they’re in. Then when you search for them you can find them easily.

Actually, you can just search for the album name. Petty easy, really.

I was passing on information which I received from what I consider to be a credible source. Graphite is a well-respected company here in Madison. It serves the University of Wisconsin and is an Apple Authorized Service Provider. I bought my latest MacBook Pro from the company and have never experienced any bad advice. Apple no longer has a store in Madison so Graphite is the only reliable source, as far as I know. I shared what I was told and it certainly sounded credible. Perhaps no one there knows what to do. I am sorry I passed on information; I thought I was being helpful. That said, YOUR response was snarky and not deserved.

But since yesterday, after I installed a security update, there are new glitches. Unless I open Photos, before I try to click "Media > Photos", I cannot even open the media Browser.


I'm not seeing that. I can get straight to the Media Browser.

léonie: Sounds like a related problem. I have submitted feedba 00004000 ck with the link you provided. Thanks!

Same problem here

Same here....I need to upload to my Etsy platform from my photos album where I place photos just for Etsy.

Can't believe this hasn't been fixed yet. 👎🏻

Do you know why they removed it? Doesn't make sense.

I believe Apple has acknowledged the problem and is working on it.

Great idea, thank you! Stupid we have to do it!

Not sure HOW to add the unique keyword to pictures I want to move to a project. I have a MacBook Pro. Can you spare a couple of minutes to 'talk' me through it? Thanks!

this is definitely an idi◯tic change! it was a useful and convenient design, I do think many would want it back!

So... the guy went in back and talked to the other guy, who claimed to have talked to Apple Support, who told him things they've told nobody else. That's your source?

Thank you, Ciddfrench. I appreciate it.

My albums are definitely there, I just can't choose a particular photo to drop in, say, a FB post unless it's something I recently uploaded to my library. I have over 15,000 pictures! Time-consuming.

I don't own a business but I understand and totally agree with you, it is insanity to expect the millions of Photos user to go back and add key words. Inconcievable!


Thank you for testing this. I hope it is not a problem with my new MBA or my iCloud Settings. My Mac is syncing with iCloud and the Shared iCloud Photos Library.