Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

In PHOTOS how to expoert and import photos in sequence?

Hello,

 

I am getting more and more disappointed by apple mainly around PHOTOS & iCloud, so many things do not work .... it is crazy).

 

I try to do something very basic:

1.     Export (from MAC A) an album in sequence (the album is defined in a manual sequence) 

2.     Import that album in another MAC B (PHOTOS) and display it in the same sequence as the original

 

Of course I export in sequence (pic 1, 2, 3, 4, etc) but when I import it goes total out of sequence and given I have a lot of albums I see there is no apparent logic, one display 1,2,3 and then 656, 657, and then 11 etc. The other album something totally different. 

Also it is not the classical issue of 1, 10, 11….19, 2, 20, 21 etc

 

If someone has an idea it would be great !

 

Seems that Apple can't event do this.... 

 

thx

Regards,

Michael

17 replies

Michael_CH wrote:

hello Leonie, so first thank you, you seem more competent than the apple support....
I applied this on a mac with 20k photos and it worked but one problem remains....
The sorting is now going like 1, 10, 100, 101 to 109, 20, etc
An idea? I guess the script can be adapted to (probably add zeros in front of nor, eg, 001, 002, etc)

Many thx !
...
regards,
Michael

Michael, instead of batch exporting with sequential filenames you could prefix the titles in the album with padded numbers. Then export with the title as the filename.

When you export edited versions from Photos, they will keep the titles, and you can sort them by the title after reimporting.


Here is a script by Old Toad: Batch Change Title to Text w/Padded Seque… - Apple Community


For the photos in an album to be sorted the same in the Finder they should be sequentially titled as muguy mentioned.


That can be done several ways:


1 - using the Album method from the export per muguy.

2 - using sequential from the export window:



There's a 3rd way. You can arrange the photos in an album the way you want them and retitle them with this AppleScripts from users:


Batch Change Title to Text w/Padded Sequential Numbers

Batch Change Title to Capture Date-Description-Padded Sequential Numbers


Then export the photos using the Title as the new file name. That will put them in the same order as you had them in the album.


The scripts compiled as an applications can be downloaded from this tutorial site:  P01 - Applescripts from Photos’ User Tips Compiled as Applications  


Michael_CH wrote: ... (3 filter possible, name, date up, date down and order in name sequence does not work).

It would have worked in Photos 4 on Mojave, but since then the filename will no longer be used as the default title, when sorting the photos (Sorting Albums by Title in Photos - Chang… - Apple Community). You would have to copy the filename to the title field in the Info.

You could try to use an Apple Script to batch copy the filename stored the title.



There is a new solution, I think. Photos Workbench from Houdah Software has a clever batch title routine that now supports custom ordering in Photos. It looks like this:

My example would sort by date, but you can put the counter first. The counter can have from 1 to 5 places.


For "Method" you can also find and replace text in titles. Really useful!

The sorting is now going like 1, 10, 100, 101 to 109, 20, etc

Right-- it sorts alphabetically, but the sequencing uses numbers of different lengths instead of using 001, 002... 014 ... 123, etc. I have fixed this, outside of Photos, with GraphicConverter which has a batch renaming function. But it was still tedious, adding 00 to the first 9, and adding 0 to the second 100, so they all had 3 digit numbers. I could then use GraphicConverter to quickly copy all the file names to the titles. But I haven't figured out anything better.

Not by default, no. However, if you manipulate the metadata to match the file name, they can then be sorted by title. If you sync using iCloud, your albums will align.

Michael_CH wrote:

...
Comment for Apple: So by Apple I need "to program" to have Photos (between apple devices) in order and I need to pay super premium Apple prices for this???? I find this absolutely crazy!

For the time being you could also simply write the numbers sequence numbers into the title of the photo.

And send feedback to Apple, as muguy suggested. Apple keeps improving Photos, and adding requested feature, albeit it may take a while until frequently requested features will be added. The very first version of Photos did not even allow us to sort the photos in the albums by the title or to add location markers.


As léonie has pointed out (here or somewhere else?) Photos, apparently by willful neglect, does not support manually ordering in albums. You can do it, but you can't do all the things that go with it, and you have the feeling the makers are frowning at you while you do it.

When you export, select file naming, sequential to keep your library photos in whatever order you made

If you're looking for features that are not part of the delivered app, yes. Leave feedback at apple.com/feedback. You may also want to investigate more robust photo library software if you need options beyond those that work for most people.

Thx :-) this I did (of course) the export works well, my photo and count are in the right order.


The issue is when I import them, then there is no way to have then in the right (sequential) order (3 filter possible, name, date up, date down and order in name sequence does not work).


Try it (note: but make sure your original library order is customised = not in date order)

thx - iCloud not an option as per another of my "post" it simply DOES NOT WORK (at all).

But how stupid is this that you can export in sequence and not import/display in sequence??? I mean, seriously???

Thanks for the response and info ! I'll check this but it look complex.


Comment for Apple: So by Apple I need "to program" to have Photos (between apple devices) in order and I need to pay super premium Apple prices for this???? I find this absolutely crazy!

hello Leonie, so first thank you, you seem more competent than the apple support....

I applied this on a mac with 20k photos and it worked but one problem remains....

The sorting is now going like 1, 10, 100, 101 to 109, 20, etc

An idea? I guess the script can be adapted to (probably add zeros in front of nor, eg, 001, 002, etc)


Many thx !

...

regards,

Michael

thx for the info - some are using scripts, they work but I have not found one yet that will bring this in the right sequence (on this nor topic). Our Apple friends make it dame complicated for such a basic "thing"....

Hi Leonie, just in case you missed this one, though you might have an idea :-), merci !


hello Leonie, so first thank you, you seem more competent than the apple support....

I applied this on a mac with 20k photos and it worked but one problem remains....

The sorting is now going like 1, 10, 100, 101 to 109, 20, etc

An idea? I guess the script can be adapted to (probably add zeros in front of nor, eg, 001, 002, etc)


Many thx !

...

regards,

Michael

Hello Leonie, "I allow myself" to come back to you on this (raison being that you really know what you talk about).


My issue with the above solution is:

  1. I have all my pics (100k) on my master MAC (proper sorted) --> I do not want to rename picture on this MAC (don't want to take any risk there + I have identical pictures in various albums)
  2. I make a manual extract that I copy on another MAC (for this I export the pic in sequence 1,2,3,4, etc)
  3. I applied one of your above recommendation that basically copy the file name into the picture title
  4. The problem now is that the sorting goes 1, 10, 11 etc. Now the solution you proposed above would require that I change the export sequence from my main MAC by renaming the pic on my main MAC (which I do not want to do). Would there be a script that I could run on my second MAC that would add those missing "0" for sorting properly the pic?


Many thanks for your great help,

regards,

Michael