Sorry. Wasn't trying to be a jerk. Annoyed with Apple, not you.
Account Authorization options weren't greyed out. When I selected "Authorize this computer," it said that all 5 authorizations were used up. When I selected "Deauthorize," it said I hadn't yet authorized this computer, so that wasn't relevant.
Third, I just meant that you were implying I hadn't done the sorta baseline research to try and fix the problem myself. I was encouraging you to see that I wasn't the only person having this issue, just in case you thought it was primarily due to a mistake I was making. Not trying to teach the Googles. :)
Finally, indeed I called Apple as people recommended in other threads. After a bit of "Wow, this is really weird what's going on?" on the part of the support person, they deauthorized the other computers remotely.
Very strange indeed, and annoying there's no self-administered fix. Thanks for trying to help, and apologies if I came off brusque.
-t