Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

GO menu> RECENTS FOLDER IS A DISASTER

Yeah, I'm an older user. Twice over the years I've been bitten by this nonstandard Recent files list and accidentally removed actual valuable files recently accessed.


NONE of the apps on Mac behave this way, only the OS Recents area. -- normally when you access an app's Recent Files area, you can clear it without trashing the ACTUAL FILES. I expect the exact same behavior from the Recents folder in the Finder's Go menu, or at least a WARNING FLAG- "You are about to trash actual files. Do you wish to continue?"


You know? Folks? Hello? Anybody home? Anybody testing?


Twice I was on a rush schedule and cleared the Go menu's Recents folder and twice I've lost real files. By the time I realized what happened I had already cleared my trash can, which I do every day. I half-expected an intermediate storage area where the Recent files could be rescued.


THIS BEHAVIOR IS NOT EXPECTED.


Best as always,

Loren

15 replies

Very sure. Both of the above replies (thank you) appear to be inaccurate. I wiped out the file list. I expected to CLEAR the list, not DELETE the files. It slipped my memory that this list is different from a typical app Clear Recent Files, which is benign and to my eye, this is a real AHIG violation.


Here's my best reply, from another Apple Community thread--


What happens if I delete my recents folder on Mac?


What occurs when I remove Recents on a Mac? Items will be moved to Trash when files from the Recents folder are deleted. This will remove the File from the disk rather than eliminate things from the list. And in most circumstances, if you clear the Trash after that, the File will be permanently deleted.


I acknowledge that the Recents menu and also the sidebar version of Recents, are not deletable, they are virtual constructs. But CONTENT deletion has been my experience, twice-- and I consider it a potentially disastrous feature. Mac Finder's Go menu> Recents should behave exactly as Mac app Clear Recents work-- they simply clear the list. That is what I expected - and deletion happened twice because I forgot from the previous episode I encountered a few years ago that they were moved to the Trash, and then unknowingly deleted!


The simplest fix- Apple dev should add a simple dialog triggered by any Go>Recents ops, with three buttons: Clear List | Move to Trash | Cancel.


Then even idiots like me know what I'm doing.


Best as always,

Loren

Sorry Luis but I think you misunderstand the problem. Loren is not talking about the >GO > recent folders > clear recent folders option. She is refering to >GO > RECENTS that lists individual files not folders and has no "clear" command. Deleting these files does indeed move them to the trash, They are not "alias" as most Mac users would expect.

As others have told you already, deleting the Recents list does NOT delete the actual files.

Files are named with the names you chose, and stored wherever you have put them - they could be in your Documents folder, your Desktop, etc.


Maybe it is just that you probably don't remember where they were, but then

you can also SEARCH for them - using Spotlight, or using Finder directly.



For the last time, Clear the List does NOT delete the files.

We are not looking over your shoulder, and cannot know exactly which steps you took, or which files you had that appear to be missing - but if they are indeed missing (and not just misplaced, or simply you are not able to find them, for some reason), it's due to some other action, NOT from clearing the Recents list.

You can either try to find the files - and maybe we can help there, if you tell us more information about what you are trying to find; or decide once and for all that they are gone, and then sorry, there is nothing we can do to help.


A final note: every Mac user should have at least a Time Machine backup, unless their files are not important to them. If you have, then you can always recover your files from the backup.

If I may try again with 5 illustrations. if that may help


1 - Finder >> Recent Folders



2 - Finder >> Recent Folders >> Documents




3 - Finder >> Recent Folders 00004000 >> Documents >> Open Documents


Yes, there is a File called " Personal Finances Moneydance "


What we understand or at least I understand


Is you want to Clear the History of Finder



To achieve that specific thing - easy >> Clear Menu


The Menu of Finder is then Cleared



4 - Clear Finder Menu


5 - Resulting in



I omitted to mention - the File called " Personal Finances Moneydance " is still located in Documents

Loren Miller1 wrote:

The delete action is established-- the Recents list, when cleared is copied without your knowledge to the TRASH CAN.

That's incorrect. Nothing is moved to the Trash. The Only thing Finder > Go > Recent Folders > Clear Menu does is delete a small file that keeps track of what folders you opened.

How are you "clearing" the Finder Recents folder from the Go menu? All it does it open the Recents folder. In any case, your signature indicates you are running Ventura 13.5. You should update to Ventura 13.7.2.

Part 1 of 2


There are two Terminal commands that may Clear the " Finder >> Go >> Recent Folder >> history


This action, does not Delete the Actual Files


It only deletes the Recent Folder >> History


Terminal commands below


defaults delete com.apple.finder GoToField


OR


defaults delete com.apple.finder GoToFieldHistory


Part 2 of 2


If you have used or are using Time Machine Backup Utility  you maybe able to Restore the Deleted Files 


For future purposes


To truly protect your non replaceable Data


Have a 3-2-1 Rescue Plan in place and always current


3 Backups using 2 methods and 1 off site incase of natural disaster or un-natural disaster.


Each of the above should be done to a Dedicated Single Purposed External Drive 


Below link is intended to augment what TM Backup does 


https://bombich.com


Ok, I see... the OP is using Go->Recents. Yes, this is a problem.

I am sorry that I and others were thinking of something different.


IMO, this one "Recents" is a completely useless thing. I have removed it from Sidebar, and I hardly ever use the Go menu in Finder; I never had noticed that Recents even appears there.


That said, it should be noted that any Mac user ought to understand what explicitly moving a file to the trash does...

Just to add, clearing the Recent Folders Menu does not erase/delete anything on my Macs.

The delete action is established-- the Recents list, when cleared is copied without your knowledge to the TRASH CAN. In effect, it deletes actual files and any random Empty Trash command finishes the job.


No warnings!!


Thanks for the terminal commands but I'm an average, not a power user. I didn't buy a Mac to hack Unix.

Time Machine tip may turn out to be useful!


Best as always,

Loren



OP wrote " The simplest fix- Apple dev should add a simple dialog triggered by any Go>Recents ops, with three buttons: Clear List | Move to Trash | Cancel. "


Adding a New Feature into macOS 13 Ventura this late in the development of macOS 13 ?


It is highly, not probable


The New Feature your are potentially asks for does not exit in macOS 14 nor in macOS 15


What makes one think it would be added to Ventura ?


Good luck

as stated, Clearing the recent list does not move files to the trash. Are you sure that you are not moving/deleting the files instead?

Go try but alas .... 😞

muguy wrote:

as stated, Clearing the recent list does not move files to the trash. Are you sure that you are not moving/deleting the files instead?

Self correction 😂


Good try but alas .... 😞