Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

How do I get Finder windows to hold their settings?

Reading in other discussions, I see some folks are having problems with desktop icons moving around. My desktop icons are fine and stay put, but my Finder windows continually rearrange themselves to whatever random design Lion wants to give them.


They will not retain size, toolbar on / off, arrange by / sort by, icon size or grid spacing etc. For a while I thought I had the problem sorted by leaving the main User window open when I shut down at night, but this 'solution' didn't hold either.


I have worked my way through the View options, tried resetting defaults etc etc, but either there's nothing I can do about it (bug?) or I am missing something simple.


Any thoughts would be appreciated. TIA

56 replies

In the finder options there is a check box "Always open in _______ view" If that's checked it should remember. There's also the option to arrange and sort by in the options. You'll find the options when you right click in the finder window area "Show View Options" Hope that helps!

Thx very much for the quick reply - yes I have gone down that track. I have also tried trashing the plist for the finder and relaunching (also restarting the Mac) but still no joy. I have no third party items installed (except Perian which I doubt is related to this) so it is a bit of a puzzle.


I also accept these are early days in the OS so maybe something will kick in - but it is very frustrating! It's an issue I would like to reolve...

I have also been frustrated by this behavior. I have tried the Finder View menu "Show View Options" on the folders but settings are not remembered (or they are ignored in Lion). I position windows for various folders where I want them, with the sort and size and view that I want. Different folder windows have different settings. When I first set the windows as I want them, the folder windows will re-open correctly. However, after a few minutes they will open in the wrong locations and sizes, with the sort reset back to Name, and the view set to List. It doesn't seem to matter what windows are re-opened first.


How does such a bug get past Apple QA? Wonder what Steve sees on his Macs?

For me "New Finder windows show: .." does not remember. I have mine set to the name of my HD but after restarts (I think) it wants to reset to my user folder. When that happens and I open Finder Preferences to check the pull down tab, that setting has reverted to blank.


(Could this in any way be related to the fact that my Safari does not remember my log-in to My.Yahoo.com? Though there is a check box that used to 'keep me logged in for two weeks' and it is still checked, about every third time I open a Safari home window, I must log in again. Oddly here, Firefox does not misbehave this way.)

same issue, driving me nutty.


I love many things in Lion but this issue remindes me of my Utilities Folder in Leopard and Snow. it NEVER wanted to remember I wanted it to sort by name and be like some icon size...


Now it's moved to many other folders!!!! the funny thing is, my Utilities folder actualy remembers all my command J settings now!? (well more often than others, including Applications now.)


BUG report time

just for info, in my post above relating memory loss of window preferences to a log-in to Yahoo, those are/were totally separate. The Yahoo issue is resolved and affected many people. It was written about widely I found. And it is fixed.

I may have discovered a tidbit that could help for now.

I noticed a folder earlyer today that has yet to get scrampbled. This folder is NOT set to always open in any view type, but it is set to snap to grid and has icons organized by and to where I want them.


So, maybe we can avoid the scramble for now by not setting always open in check boxes. It's not like it isn't simple to hit command 1 to get icon view if it's not.


Just an observation and idea looking for validation still.

Nope, i was wrong... it seems once a folder starts having this issue, even turning off the always open in icon doesn't fix it.


Not sure what is different between the folders affected and the ones so far unaffected. Other than maybe they never had always open in icon under Lion, nor do I recall using Clean up or otherwise moving any icons in them.


Also not sure where Finder is getting it's scrambled icon mess, but it seems to always toss them back into the same piles of overlapping mess. With a few changes now and then... Odd.

I have this problem too, and it's maddening. My latest effort fo fix it has been to make .DS_Store read only using the Terminal. This will work for directories that you never alter; I did it to my home directory. If you do it to directories that change, the results will be undefined, because the Finder will be unable to write changes to the .DS_Store file reflecting the position of the new files.




To do this, open Terminal in /Applications/Utilities, and then type:




cd "/Path/to/directory/to/fix"




Replace the path with the folder you need to fix. If you're not sure what it is, you can just type "cd " (without the quotes, but note the space after the letters 'cd') and then drag the folder you want to fix onto the Terminal window. Then press return.




Now, type:



chmod 444 .DS_Store




Make sure you include the period at the beginning of the .DS_Store name. Press return. This will effectively lock the .DS_Store file and prevent the Finder from screwing it up. Your icon positions and window settings will be fixed in place until you make the .DS_Store file writable again. To do that, repeat Step 1 above, and change Step 2 as follows:




chmod 644 .DS_Store




That will return the .DS_Store file to its original state and undo the changes you made.


I have tested this only on my home directory, which never changes. Doing this to directories to which files are added and removed will result in undefined behavior. It will not damage your computer or your files, but Finder windows for that directory will not behave in a predictable fashion.

Having the same issues here. Only started in Lion, and not fixed in 10.7.1.


New set window seems to hold position and size for a short time and then it reverts back to whatever Lion wants to do with it.

same for me - just posted this:



Why does the Finder forget my settings for folders and desktop - I set some folders to be viewed in list, others in icon - 10 minutes later, Lion has forgotten these settings. I am constantly resetting my folder views for my workflow and I am wasting my time. I can set the folder view, close the folder, immediately reopen and it is changed to whatever the machine decides - there is no pattern to it, icons appear as list, I lose my backgrounds, the windows are different size settings to what I set just 1 minute ago. No matter what settings I have for a folder, they are ignored 100% of the time by the System/Finder/GU eye-candy department. I don't want folder icons at 128 x 128, nor do I want folder windows to be half my screen - I want GUI to be mine not a random hash of views.


I have reset ACLs and repaired permissions, I have deleted various Finder prefs and reinstalled the system. I hate Lion because the emphasis is on eye candy rather than function. I want a system that remembers my settings - Mac OS has been doing this for years, but suddenly under Lion, user settings and preferences are optional, to be disregarded at a whim by the system. Why is it so hard for the Finder to remember/respect my settings? What's so difficult about respect a folder view in list mode and another in icon view?


How many times do I need to zero my drive and reinstall Lion until it actually works?


I have posted details to the feedback page but for all I know, these postings are ignored/trashed/ignored for all the non-improvements in 10.7.1 over the base install. Has anyone solved this massive GUI bug in Lion? There are certainly lots of posts on theese forums with similar issues but I have yet to find a solution of any sorts.

I'm having the same issue. Could this be related to the Spotlight issue? In Lion the Spotlight keeps re-indexing my hard drive every time the system stars. Could it be resetting DS Store files?


The strange thing is that in my case the desktop icons stay put. Lion only messes the icons in Finder windows.

Same issue here.

Desktop icons stay put, but some of the Finder windows get messed up.

Somehow I have the suspicion that it has to do with saving things into those folders.

Not sure.

Let's hope Apple nails this one in 10.7.2... (and the spotlight)

Have a look at this one, folks... From MacFixit.


Icon and window positions shifting in OS X


http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-20104006-263/icon-and-window-positions-shif ting-in-os-x/#ixzz1XVntdfxq


I used "Nude" to clean out the files, and a full restart.


So far, so good... Will report back in again if it all falls over!

I've been considering doing similar.


ran nude and it just crashed.

ran IceClean and it just hung.


eventualy unmounted Bootcamp and my Time Machine drives so it would ignore them, and ran this in terminal.


sudo find / -name ".DS_Store" -depth -exec rm {} \;


then restarted computer.


now to see what happens...

24 hours later and the windows seem to be holding their positions and remembering what they are supposed to look like, plus, importantly, the icons are where I left them.

That is not to say they will stay that way - I thought I had it all sorted once before!


I don't have bootcamp or similar running at all.

"Nude" did take it's time, I'll admit, but it said it found and disposed of over 1700 files, so I guess that would take a while to do.🙂


One note, an external (firewire) drive I have attached has never lost it's settings, not even once... The problem has only been my main hard drive on my iMac.

In the meantime, it's fingers crossed (as well as toes, legs, etc). This is one of the very few things that really bugs me about Lion. I'd like to think it is sorted!

I used OnyX to delete the .DS_Store files on my hard disk. After the restart, I set my windows the way I like them and closed them. A few minutes later I re-opened the windows. They opened in the wrong locations, wrong sizes, wrong views. So, delet 00004000 ing the .DS_Store files may not always restore the Finder's sanity. It didn't for me. This has to be a serious bug in Lion Finder.


So, besides this serious bug, I also have the frequently reported problem of the keyboard illumination setting being ignored. I have mind set to OFF. But after a few minutes of darkness, the keyboard is illuminated. I then manually turn if off (or dim it down). A few minutes later, the keyboard is illuminated at full brightness. I have reset the SMC. No change. I also repaired permissions; no change.


Both of these problems appeared immediately after upgrading my MacBook Pro from 10.6.8 to 10.7. Both problems still exist with 10.7.1 While at first glance, these problems should not be related, the fact that settings I make are being ignored does make me wonder if they are related somehow. Is the same Apple engineer involved with the code for both? Is the same QA person involved with testing both? Hum...

We have downgrades our new Mini i7 to Snow Leopard because to this eggretious error. I am looking forward to hearing about the success or failure of Nude.

Same issue here.


I prefer List view for all of my windows, sorted by Name, with a vertical orientation for the window. Sometimes Finder will hold this for a while, but more typically after the passage of anywhere from a few minutes to several hours (even after a Restart), it falls back to a horizontal window view and ignores the Name sort.

Dang! Okay, everything has been fine and I really thought I had cracked it. External drives, main hard drives - all held settings, window size etc then tonight, randomly, it all turned to custard.

Firstly opening a folder opened right where the parent folder was - size the same, setting the same although I had previously set it to icon view (not list view like the parent folder) and a different size, based on top left corner of screen.

Then I went to the applications folder from my main Finder window - then back to home, only to find everything exactly where Lion wanted it - no resemblance at all to where I had everything placed and it had been happily residing since Saturday.


Is anyone from Apple actually reading this? This is hugely frustrating!


BTW, external drives continue to hold settings and continue merrily...


😢 😢 😢

Yeap, don't bother deleteing the .DS_Store files, the probem has retunred for me as well....


the most frustrating aspect is how it seems to go back to a cluttered mess as if reverting to another saved version of something stores who knows where. the same icons that pile on top of each other do it again, other move around...

Oooh... Freaky! Visual gym 00004000 nastics... Booted the iMac (shut down last night with the main Finder window open and all icons set where I wanted them) and watched as the window reopened itself - with the icons where I wanted them... And then watched as they reorganised themselves to suit Lion right before my eyes without me even touching the mouse or keyboard.

A screen shot of the wibndow compared to one taken last week shows Lion was putting the icons in exactly the same places including piling them on top of each other...

I think you are right, Steven... Lion is storing info somewhere and defaulting to it over and above our own user settings. But WHY!?!?

This is a Lion bug which most likely will be be fixed in 10.7.2. I agree that it is extremely annoying, and something that Apple must fix soon.

we can hope.

I also have many icon layout problems with 10.7.1 Finder.

For me also the Finder window size always defaults to 4,0 1436,878.

I change this in the com.apple.finder.plist file to 0,0 1440,878 which is fullscreen.

It never sticks. When I recheck the plist it has reverted to 4,0 1436,878.

It somehow always finds a way to revert to this setting.

Interestingly when I go to the user library folder in Finder I only see one com.apple.finder.plist file. However, if I do a spotlight search for the file within that folder (~/Library) I find seven instances of the file all named com.apple.finder.plist !

Hoping 10.7.2 sorts this.

As a follow-up, I tried the utility Nude (as per the suggestion of wyrmsmaug in this discussion). I allowed Nude to act on my entire Documents folder and since then (two nights) have had no further window sizing or View Option problems. I'll be keeping an eye on this, but for the moment I'm happy.


In regad to the utility, itself, I had problems with Nude crashing after dragging files to it. However, it seems to have done its work prior to each crash. While the action by Nude was almost instantaneous, the utility does not provide much feedback and little or no information about what it is doing. However, I won't complain about details so long as it works.

Follow-up:


Unfortunately, Nude does not seem to have made changes that would hold (they only held together for about 3 days). Window sizing again became erratic, today. So, I tried the utility "iRemove .DS_Store files". It took much longer than Nude to handle the removal of the .DS_Store files, but provided feedback at the end of the process indicating that all of those files on the mounted disks had been deleted. This utility did not crash.


After a Restart, the window sizing and options seem to be holding; however, I'll keep an eye on it and see if the problem returns.

Follow-up:


The fix provided by "iRemove .DS_Store" did not last long (about 15 hours). However, what I noticed is that it seemed to be fine until I logged out, another user of my computer logged-in, and then when I logged-back in, the problem re-emerged. Not sure if that was coincidental or has some actual relationship to the problem. However, at the moment, I am back to square one. Hope Apple will be able to address this at the system level rather than users having to address this via third-party utilities and the repeated need to delete all .DS_Store files.

From my observations there is clearly some kind of other repository of finder window settings I'm not yet aware of because even after removeing all .DS_Store files, some of my OLD folders (pre OS 10) seem to still revert (to some extent) back to how they would have been under OS 9? Icon sizes even in one folder the size was very small with names on the right, and it reverted to that again.


I did a search for Desktop DB and Desktop DF files etc., and only found 4 in folders unrelated to the ones reverting to such settings, and only on one drive.


something somepace is clearly storing settings, yet at the moment I have not found where...

I've noticed a seemingly miraculous reversion once or twice. In the case of folder in which I had organized my icons just the way I wanted, at one point, the view settings got scrambled, the icons got scrambled, and I figured that was that, I'm screwed. But a few moments later --not sure what I did, possibly closed and re-opened the window once again, possibly fooled with the view settings-- the original icon arrangement reappeared.


I'm not sure I have any folders arranged in recognizable ways that go back as far as OS9, but I definitely have the impression that the view-setting-scrambling affects older folders less than newer ones. When a newer folder gets hit, there's nothing left of the previous view. I would only notice in the cases of folders I've set to icon view and arranged the icons per my workflow. For an older 00001AA4 folder, in my experience, the icons settings are stable or nearly so. I think I've seen a few icons shift around while most stay as I arranged them.


As for "other repositories" of window settings... I think Finder knows nothing at all about folders that it hasn't been told to open for a while. When you open a folder, Finder almost certainly reads .DS_Store and displays the folder accordingly. Probably when you close that folder, Finder saves the settings back to .DS_Store.


Let me make some wild-*** guesses about some of the details:


a) There are multiple versions of the .DS_Store file format over the years as the Finder has evolved, and


b) the read step transforms the information in .DS_Store to a convenient in-memory format, and the write step transforms that format back to the latest .DS_Store storage specification --or not, possibly, for older folders; and


c) that there's some amount of buffering going on.


I think that a relatively minor glitch in any of these steps could scramble view settings. For example, a problem with the buffering could account for the apparent reversion you and I have seen. (Buffering problem? Might look something like this: the in-memory copy should be erased when the data is written back to the .DS_Store file but isn't.) I'm suggesting that there probably isn't a completely separate method of recording view settings, just a problem with managing the data that originates in .DS_Store files and gets written back to those files.

Like many others, I have been suffering from this problem since installing Lion. I've tried various fixes noted in this and other discussions but without success. After reading this article:


http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/os_x_lion_disabling_resume_one_program_at _a_time/


I got curious and wondered if this setting was confusing the Finder. So, I turned it off and relaunched the Finder. I then opened several folder windows and set them the way I want them to appear. For each folder, I used the Show View Options in the Finder's View menu. That was several hours ago.


So far, the windows now open up correctly. Correct view, correct size, correct location.


When I've tried the other solutions, they always failed within a short period. This solution seems to be longer lived. And perhaps it explains why some users have had the problem and some haven't.


If you are experiencing the problem, give this solution a try.


Mike

Thx Mike - but for me the problem persistes whether I have the restore box ticked or not. The solution appears to be deeply hidden in the system somewhere.

One thing that concerns me is that all the reading I have been doing about 10.7.2 doesn't have anything about a fix for this (unless I am missing something ) and I hate to say it but the problem has now spread to one of my external drives which, until now, had been untouched by the Lion visual gymnastics with my icons.


Other than this issue, I'm really enjoying Lion! (Although I found myself using a PC at work the other day and starting to panic whem my window wouldn't scroll down for me... It worked once I started to think in reverse...) <grin>

Well, my fix failed this morning. One window moved and resized. But the others have stayed correct (so far).


Sure would be nice if Apple had a "known issues" web page. Then we could all stop wasting our time trying to fix issues we see that are in fact known bugs (that may or may not be fixed in future updates).


Mike

It's over 24 hours now, since the 10.7.2 update and the icons are holding their positions. Looks like this bug is fixed...

unfortunately not so fo me - still random size and layout - time to put a large hammer to my hard drive!

Hmmm... so far my icons 'appear' more stable, but they appear to only hold settings if I have more than one window open when I shut down and open up the next day (still to test this theory further).


However, I still have an odd window problem... (which existed before the 10.7.2 update and which I assumed to be part of the whole not holding settings problem).


If I have a window open (e.g. set to list view) and open another folder, the second folder window opens as list regardless of previous settings (e.g. icon view) and slightly offset from the first window...


Overall I have yet to be convinced the problems are fixed, maybe even not yet started on???

Installed 10.7.2 yesterday. I set up my folders the way I want them using the Finder:View:Show View Options. All was well for about two minutes. After that, when re-opening the windows, they opened up in the wrong view.


So, using the Show View Options to set the folder didn't stick.


BUT, NOT using it does seem to stick. For example, just move a folder window to where you want it and set it how you want it to look (I use the buttons at the top of the window and/or the contextual menu). That position, size, and view seems to stick. Even after almost 24 hours.


I just did a restart (to reset the SMC on the MBP to try again to fix the keyboard illumination issue). After the restart, the windows open where they should. Whew!


So, the key is to NOT use the Show View Options.

This from MacFixit (Sat 15 October)


Finder Icon reorganization (fixed)
A number of people found that in Lion their icon organization and settings on the desktop and other windows in Icon view would change randomly, especially after restarting or logging out and logging back in. The problem appears to have been addressed so icons should stay in their proper locations.

Read more: http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-20120069-263/os-x-10.7.2-what-it-fixed-and- what-it-didnt/#ixzz1ap4T1NZd

Not fixed for me.

okay... Icons are holding their settings for me in both the main drive window and for any external drives as well, which is great.


However not all the window settings stick - for example whether the window is set to icon or list view, or placement (location) of the window. This, however, to make matters difficult, appears to be a random problem - no logic to the manifestation of the problem at all. Some hold, others don't, some hold sometimes, but not others.

*** Often a window will pick up the attributes of the foremost window if I have more than one.


Odd behaviour, but at least the main one of rearranging itself appears to have been solved (for me at least).


Thanks to all those contributing here... It makes for interesting reading.


Message was edited by: wyrmsmaug

I have to agree, some folders have maintained some settings. However I for sure have seen other settings not stick yet. One example is my Applications folder. I want it in Icon view, sorted by name with a bit bigger icons, and the window streached to full height. It sticks for s time, but eventualy ends up back to normal size, snap to gid, and the window is small...

i keep getting my windows re-sized in this most irritating 2'' tall by 3'' wide - CONSTANTLY !!!


this is completely USELESS on my 27'' iMac, specially when you have 50, 80 or 100 files , folders inside AND have invested the time & effort in sizing them up according to your preference..


what an enormous waste of time & energy - or is this a new ''thing'' aimed at those who skip going to the gymn ?

finder still not remembering to open in my set director on a fresh 107.2 system.

Just out of curiosity, out of all those suffering here from this Finder problem, do any of you have TotalFinder running ?

Not here. don't even know what it is

Not me, either. What's TotalFinder?


My current theory is that there were two parts to the problem: one, in the Finder, was fixed by 10.7.2. The second is that .DS_Store files --containing windows settings-- aren't being saved due to permissions problems. I'm pretty sure the Finder runs with user-level privileges. As the caching of the content --which includes key window settings-- is completely invisible to us users, it is hard to connect the dots. But if someone is very observant and can detect a clearly failing case, then try to manually overwrite the operative .DS_Store, obviously with the same user-level privileges, my theory says the operation will fail.


Yeah, it's a bit crazy, but ... anyone got a better theory?

Well OK, so a couple of you don't have TotalFinder. I have & I thought it was that but it seems I *MAY* have found a solution to the problem (this applies to everyone who either has or hasn't got TotalFinder BTW).

I'm pretty sure in saying that all changes to a Finder window are saved in the preferences file COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST which is located in your ~/Users/YOURACCOUNTNAME/Library/Preferences. Am I right ?

Well, going by that theory I realised that if you set up your Finder window with all your favourite settings, e.g. correct font 00004000 size, correct window size, set the "New Finder Windows Show" setting to whichever location you want,etc... and then you made that file READ ONLY & LOCKED the file, you therefore wouldn't lose your changes to any of the Finder settings you've made even after multiple logout's/reboots/shutdown's, because you're denying OSX the right to change the settings at anytime by making the file READ ONLY. OK ?

This doesn't affect the Finder's sidebar as those settings are stored in COM.APPLE.SIDEBARLISTS.PLIST, so you can continue to add/remove stuff from your sidebar even though :-)


Here's what I did & hopefully it should work for all of you (I've written this out in a Dummies Guide Style so that everyone can understand what to do)...


1) Close all currently open Finder windows & then open one again so it should be showing your current default settings.

2) Change all the Finder settings to whatever you want e.g. correct font size, correct window size, set the "New Finder Windows Show" setting to whichever location you want, etc...

3) Open another Finder window & go to ~/Users/YOURACCOUNTNAME/Library/Preferences & locate your COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST file (ignore the COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST.LOCKFILE file).

4) RIGHT CLICK once on the COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST & select GET INFO. Now carry out the following instruction in this order, and I'll explain later why...(*)

5) At the bottom of the Info Panel should be a section called SHARING & PERMISSIONS. Open it by clicking on the sideways triangle & it should reveal something like this...


User uploaded file


6) Where it says your account name, it should be showing READ & WRITE ACCESS Privilege's. Click the dropdown triangles next to where it says READ & WRITE ACCESS & change that to READ ONLY Privilege's (FOR YOUR ACCOUNT NAME ONLY !!), like I have in this screen capture I provided above. Don't change the Privilege's for any other account that may be showing in your SHARING & PERMISSIONS, as the changes your making to the Finder only apply to YOUR ACCOUNT.

7) In the same Info Panel near the top is a section called GENERAL. In this section is an option called LOCKED. Click the box so that it should then look like this...


User uploaded file

8) Now look back down to the SHARING & PERMISSIONS section you changed before & make sure that the READ ONLY Privilege is still set to READ ONLY. (*)= I say this because I found that as I LOCKED the file, I saw that my Privilege's changed back to READ & WRITE for some reason, so I changed them back to READ ONLY again & this time they were retained as well as the file being now LOCKED.

9) Close the Info Panel window & that's it !!


I've tried multiple logout's/reboots/shutdown's since I made these changes to my COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST 2 days ago & it works everytime... the window size is always the same & where it should be, the icon size is the same as I always wanted it & more importantly the "New Finder Windows Show" continues to be in the same location I want it ALL the time, compared to before where it would default back to my HOME directory after every logout/reboot/shutdown.

If this "fix" works for your account & there are other users using the same computer & they too have admin privilege's, then login as them & carry out the same procedure as described above, but making sure that you choose THEIR ACCOUNT NAME when you're in the SHARING & PERMISSIONS section !! ;-)


I hope this works for all of you :-)

Thanks for your work.


I think we are discussing two different groups of settings, each of which may be susceptible to getting scrambled.


I'm satisfied that some settings are stored in the invisible .DS_Store files in each directory (folder) because I can make a save-copy of this file, change the actual view, and see the original view of that directory restored when I restore the actual .DS_Store file from the save-copy. These settings include the "Always open in <something> view" and "Browse in <something> view" visible when you activate Finder-->View-->Show View Options.


I simply haven't looked at COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST so I'll take your word for it that some _other_ important window view parameters are stored in that file.


Sure, the method you describe will prevent Finder from messing with the COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST settings. That makes sense if somehow Finder is scrambling the settings you made before storing them to this file.. My question: what if you _want_ to re-arrange your desktop? Do you undo the changes you describe? Then, make the changes you want? After that, how do you persuade the Finder to save the new settings before you write-protect COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST again? I would expect Finder to keep those settings in memory for "a while".


A minor mystery: Why does the "Locked" control act so strangely? I don't know. If I recall correctly reading about "Locked" a very long time ago, it is maintained completely separately from file permissions. Maybe "Locked" goes back as far as System 1. It's a bit strange to have two completely independent mechanisms for write-protecting a file, and maybe what you are seeing is simply a side-effect of that strangeness. I don't think this is a particular serious issue. Is it?

Has anyone found a solution to this yet? I'm using 10.7.5 and all my Finder windows used to stay put but for months now they've all been opening up in one single location on my monitor. I move them to where I want them (I have 4 internal drives in my mac pro that back up to 4 external drives and I like to have the backup drives finder windows opened directly beneath the cooresponding internal drive finder window), I even leave them opened for awhile and access them, hoping that the mac will 'learn' and remember where I put them, but always to no avail.


The obvious question is: why did Apple do away with the Finder's ability to remember these placements, sizes, etc..., but no one will get that answer so it's pointless. The real question is the one that finds the solution. I've gone into my Finder viewer options and told the Finder window for each drive to always open and browse in column view but that has no bearing on the Finder window itself staying where I've put it.


I'm keeping my fingers crossed that someone smarter than me has found a solution. I'm opened to third party apps if that's the solution; I don't care, I'm just tired of having to move the Finder windows 50 times a day.


Thanks for any help. Fingers crossed...

I never found a reliable solution to this, except for upgrading to 10.8. But you probably won't be surprised to learn that the Finder in 10.8 is still broken when it comes to window handling. Yes, it now remembers opened windows, locations, and sizes. BUT about half the time when I log out and check the box to have apps and windows reopen when I log back in, the two Finder windows that were open fail to re-open. Other programs and their windows always re-appear. So, when this happens, I have to reopen those windows. At least they re-open in the proper locations and sizes. Considering all the issues in OS X and iOS, I suspect the code has gotten too complex for all the bugs to be eliminated, even in the latest releases.

browncoat101:


I think there may be 3 components to non-holding of Mac windows. Going back to point at which a number of people complained about this issue, suddenly. (Did this occur at the release of 10.7.0 or 10.7.1? I do not recall. Here they are:


#1. Apple broke something in the Finder that caused SOME people to have this problem. But probably the majority of MacOS users did not have the issue. My reasoning: as far as I could see there were small numbers of complaints on some major Mac-related forums. But nothing like an avalanche that would occur if it was widespread.


I was one of the unlucky people to experience this problem. And I was VERY frustrated by it, because my workflow depends heavily on icon arrangement.


#2. EINacho in the post above (30 March 2012) reports 00004000 good results with adjusting the permissions settings of the master COM.APPLE.FINDER.PLIST for your account, so this approach seems worth trying.


#3. My pet theory also involves messed-up permission settings, but with respect to the invisible file called .DS_Store that exists in every folder. As I have posted above, it seems clear that some windows settings are stored in this file. If the permissions of this file are sufficiently messed up, the Finder simply cannot save windows positions, etc. Unfortunately, this file and its permission settings are only visible to users via the command line, which is also normally the only way to fix its permissions. (I guess some 3rd party utilities could probably do the job, too.)


Clearly, Apple fixed #1 in a subsequent release for most of the people experiencing the problem. There may be some residual effects of #1 for a very few people. Considering that, and the fairly strong likelihood of a permissions problem... It would be useful if you could examine your permissions closely and see if you can correlate your issues with what's described in #2 and #3. I think you have a lot more internal disks than most people. Maybe that gives you more opportunities to have systematic permissions problems -- and for systematic exploration of the problem.


I hate to bring this up, because it seems to be such a generic fix: Have you tried Verify and Repair Disk permissions in Disk Utility?


My experience: As far as I can tell, most of my issues were solved by the later MacOS release, with the possible exception of view settings, which occasionally seem to revert to list view, from my usually-preferred icon view. Most importantly, my icon arrangements are rock-solid. If my view settings alone are getting whacked sometimes, it is an minor annoyance to me -- so minor that I really have not gone to the trouble of carefully observing and recording what actually is happening. It's really possible this is cause by something I'm doing.


HTH

Thanks for the replies, guys. I have not tried disc utility yet so I'll try that straight away, but I run those kinds of utilities pretty regularly so I doubt it will do much. But it's worth trying so thanks a ton for the suggestion.


I really don't want to upgrade to 10.8. It really bugs me that everything is becoming os iOS oriented. I've got nothing against the great mobile movement but I still sit at home and work on a mac pro all day. The user interface gets less and less desktop-user friendly as things progress. That's how I feel anyways. Besides, I've dealt with enough bad os updates in the last few years; I'm taking a break for awhile.


If the disc utility stuff doesn't work I guess I'll just continue to live with it. Thanks anyways. And thanks for all the good posts that preceeded my question. I like seeing the history of efforts to fix things.

Hey,

This bug has been bugging me too for a month or so. I tried all the above supposed fixes, but none worked for me.

BUT what did eventually do it for me was to revert the setting for "New Finder windows show" to something that's available in the default list, mine is 'macbook' (so not set a custom folder with 'Other..').

User uploaded file

I did first trash the com.apple.finder.plist file as suggested before, and started from there. That's how I noticed it when applying all my preferences one by one.

Now it remembers finder size and sidebar width for me again 🙂

(I'm on Mountain Lion 10.8.2)


Hope it helps someone out there!

Hi everyone,

Try this

1 - click on finder in top left side of ur desktop then select preferences

2 - in general icon check always open folders in a new window

3 - then select third icon of sidebar and uncheck all

4 - restart mac

5 - open finder window(u can see there is no icons in finder sidebar)

6 - again goto sidebar icon in finder - sidebar,check all icons u want to arrange sidebar in ur finder window(including desktop icon)

7 - now in finder window u can see favorites icon,infront ot that u can see show icon,click on that

8 - then it will show every icons u checked

Hope this will helpfull for all of you...🙂

I have a similar problem. Finder doesn't remember the view options for sub folders on my external storage drive. I set the folders and sub-folders view options to "always show in icon view" but only the root folder shows up in icon view and the sub-folders show in the view that finder window had last time when it was closed. Anyone else having this issue?