Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

QuickTime convert .avi to .mov with OS X Mavericks

Hello! I used QuickTime for watch any videos on OS X Mountain Lion, but now, I'm passed to OS X Mavericks and QuickTime, when I open an .avi file, convert this in a .mov file. I'm sorry for my English, I'm French and I don't know speak English very well, but what can I do for QuickTime opens on .avi and doesn't convert to .mov?

92 replies

I have found that the an older version of Quicktime Player 7 that I have installed on my 2011 Macbook Air running Mavericks still plays .avi files without the need for conversion. I also find it upsetting that the newer Quicktime is forcing the conversion upon opening the .avi files. Hope this helps.

I noticed this today, too, and it's very frustrating and takes a really long time to be able to watch the video.


Does anyone know of a way to get QuickTime to NOT convert .avi files to .mov before playing?

Galaxiemusique, Your English is great. Better than my French. Full honours to you.


I have a similar problem since "Upgrading" (what a joke) to OS Mavericks. iTunes plays sound for almost all my videos, but not for others. Format does not appear to be te problem, some MP4 work, some do not.

Any brilliant ideas (apart from microwaving the Apple Mac with sugar and cinnamon) gratefully received.


Message was edited by: dssinclair

I would like to add my voice to those ****** off by this decision by Apple to cripple QuickTime Player even further with Mavericks. Every movie that isn't a .mov, .m4v or .mp4 file has to be converted before viewing now and even small files take ages to convert and load. QT Player won't load all .mp4 files without converting as I have had quite a number of these also require "con 00004000 verting". File of .avi flavour, which is a big chunk of my older library of videos, all now have to be "converted".


Why has Apple done this? With each iteration of OS X, I have found myself using VLC more and more. QuickTime, at least for my purposes, has become even more unusable for a large amount of video from the internet. I'm really angry with Apple and don't understand why they would do this. I am on the verge of changing my defaults to open all video types with VLC and dumping QuickTime Player altogether.

You should download an add on called perain. Perain will allow you to watch many avi's through quicktime. This works a perfectly for a majority of the movies, however there will be some that wll still need converting. I suggest using VLC media player for those videos.

I've got the same problem with the addition that some of my avi files wont' finish the conversion and a message saying there has been an error would appear. This is so frustrating.

I do have Perian, and I just figured out that it's the problem. Apparently QuickTime never natively played AVI files, and using Perian is what allowed me to play them before. But Perian hasn't been updated for Mavericks support (it hasn't been updated in years), so now the files aren't playing.


I hope either Perian updates or someone comes up with a plugin like it to allow AVI files to play in QuickTime. Until then, I'll use VLC (despite it not being as clean as QuickTime 10).

I have this same issue. Now I have switched to using MplayerX which you can get on the App Store. It plays everything, uses a lot less energy than Quicktime (as per Mavericks own activity monitor) and if you are watching a video, but close the app, it will re-open the video where it left off when you open the app again. It's so much better than Quicktime and looks nicer than VLC with no borders on the video.


I hope this helps.

Will try it, will try anything that works!

Thank you

HI GalaxieMusique,


I'm french too, but I'm going to write this post in english so that everyone may understand it 😉


I have the same problem in Mavericks, but I'd say, more important, with QuickLook.


Indeed Quicklook can't read avi movies anymore. Actually it always been the case, but with Perian we were able to fix it. The problem is that Perian is no longer available for Mac OS 10.9....


I'd assume that our only hope is Apple themselves... It would be nice from Apple to creat an add-on for quicklook to be able to preview the avi movies.


In regards with quicktime, you can download QuickTime 7 here:


http://www.01net.com/telecharger/windows/Multimedia/lecteurs_video_dvd/fiches/10 0.html


and ask all the .avi movies to be played by QuickTime 7 and not QuickTime X (included into Mac OS).


Sorry for the english, we french people can make mistakes sometimes 😉


If anyone has a solution for QuickLook, please do not hesitate. This topic is becoming a real mess....

Also, if you want to make MplayerX the default app for all video files, Control click the file and go to "Get Info" then click on the "Open with:" arrow. Select the program you would like to open the file with in the drop down list, in this case MplayerX, Click on the "Change All..." button and click "continue". Now all video files will open with MplayerX.

will this allow QuickLook playing videos as well ???

Thank you “derekreilly”.

I am sorry to say that Apple seems to be morphing into Microsoft. It is totally unacceptable to knowingly release a faulty product in the sure knowledge that the user will have no option but to do the debugging. A few years ago it is precisely this that caused me to leave the MS platform which I had used since its first edition and change to Apple, which was trouble free then.

If I followed this abusive policy in my web based business, I would be out of work in no time flat.

Sooner or later one of 2 things will happen. Either Apple will wake up and stop this cynical practice, or someone will start up another company with a new platform that treats the user with respect. It has happened before, giant companies that mis-treated its clients have disappeared in the past, and not just in the electronic industry.

Yeah, quick look still works.

Thanks derekreilly,


On my iMac Quicklook doesn't work since I've installed Mavericks.


My question was, will MPlayer X installation allow QuickLook play again .avi video file ? 😕


Thank you,

Try it and see :)

This is really SAD ... we can watch Avi files with MplayerX ... and so, by setting it as default for Avi files ... but no longer you can play it on the "Get Info" tab or while seaching on a simple folder ... it used to appear a small icon with the movie instead of the Avi file icon as now ...
Let's HOPE Apple can fix this ... and makes an update to solve ... because as it is changes a lot the way to use an iMac ou Macbook !!!!! for worst ...


... if i knew it ... i would probably not upadate to Mavericks ... well it was free ... i guess it could never be near perfection !!!!!


I'm really upset ... and wondering ... How many "surprises" Mavericks will bring in the future .. i've just started to use it ... and i'm already dissapointed ...!!


APPLE ... Please ... an Update to mavericks ... pleaaaseeee....


sorry for my bad or confusing English ... but I'm Portuguese ...


Rui

Nope... Quick look still not working...


Anyway, thanks for the tips.


Apple is you can see these topics, please do something for quicklook. I want quicklook to be able to preview .avi. Ideo files.

so sad it did't work. i wish quicklook and quicktime would play my avi's


i want my thumbnail previews back.


Mavericks is a disappointment. theres more missing features than new features

May be Apple should rename "QuickTime Player" to "AV Foundation Player" - on Mavericks the "QuickTime Player" is not based on QuickTime but on "AVFoundation".


"AV Foundation" is Apple's replacement for QuickTime - QuickTime is not (and never will be) supported for 64 bit applications (and the "QuickTime Player" on Mavericks is a 64 bit application).


The "QuickTime Player" on Mavericks is converting all movies which are not H264, MP4, M4V (and may be a few more formats) because "AV Foundation" can only read / play movies with this format. Exactly the same as on iOS.


Apple's plan for now and the future: they expect you to convert all your movies. And trash all "old movie formats" (like AVI, DivX, WMV). If you have any "QuickTime VR" (panorama) movies: forget it.


It seems that Apple is ignoring that the users still need "old movie formats" and do not want to wait for movie convertion - my camera is recording AVI movies for example, and I will not buy a new camera just because Apple has this plan.


Fortunately Flip4Mac and Perian as QuickTime extensions still work on Mavericks if you use 32 bit applications. And Mavericks is supporting 32 bit applications. So this is what you can do: install Flip4Mac and Perian on Mavericks and use a 32 bit application like the old "QuickTime Player".

Thanks for the update.


Sounds sad from Apple obliging all their customers converting their old videos.... 😐


It works with QT 7, you are right but do you have any tips to make QuickLook works again ??


Thanks again,

Please Apple fix this big problem.


Working with video editing, over 3000 videos that I see in the finder the thumbnail of the video, I do not see the quick time icon named "AVI".


I need to see the little icon with a thumbnail because I have to spend 5 times more of my time to whet the videos with another compatible video and know that I need to work.


With your help, I downloaded the Quick Time 7 and now I can open the AVI without conversion begins,


but someone has solved it for thumbnails or preview the video?


An update is essential because it affects the work.


Thanks

Derek--


Are you saying that quicklook still works for you with .mov files? It's not working for me at all. Totally *****.. ;(


Does anyone have any suggestions for this?

@kenergizer

Quicklook ONLY works on .mov-files that are compressend with the right codec: h.264. All other codecs (MotionJPG, Sorensen, etc etc) won't work on quicklook - event if they're called .mov.


OS X has done another step closer towards iOS, where also only h.264 is supported. That's a shame, considering that Apple used to be the no1 company for Video artists. If you have to download all kinds of third party products (VLC, MPlayer X) just to watch your content, then I really don't see the point.

@vjPulp

Thanks for that. Yes, what a shame. My love affair with Apple is starting to fizzle...actually it's been eroding as they keep "improving" things. I think I need to go get some chocolate now.

I can understand that apple wants people to use more solid and modern formats.

But if you have a collection of movies or as me working with 3d and composeting application for nearly 15 years it is a shame.


The Quick View functionn was so nice and made work fast and easy for me.


A shame that Quick Time or AVfrankenstein is not asking you what to do. You try to open a file with the expection that the content of your footage beeing played and what the **** it starts to "convert" ?

Are you sure apple? This is kind of a dictatorship. It dosn't even ask you!


They are talking about OS is tailored to be more energy efficient, and now it starts to convert files...

I'm lost i can not find the plot.


Quick Look for videos is doomed ... thanks apple.

Thank you for posting this issue - I just rolled back to OS X Mountain Lion and 'All is Well' again. I hope Apple will take the comments in this post seriously.

Hi,

I have not found the perfect solution, but this one is the best one yet, for me at least.
Use Adobe Bridge if you can, the preview/thumbnails work perfectly.


Btw, am in the same way Jbcnk, over 4k videos for editing and.....


cu guys

Thanks Dryler but I did try and nothing happened...


Adobe Brodge isn't working for thumbnail/preview for .avi videos that aren't on H264...

Perian no longer works in Mavericks, or at least that is what is being reported. I still have it installed and Quicktime 7 still works and opens .flv, .MP4 and probably other files that it opened before.


If you have QT 7 (I have the pro version) you can do a get info on one of your movie files, select Quicktime 7 under "Open With:" and click the change all button. From now on double clicking any file of that type will open it in Quicktime 7 instead of Quicktime X. No Quick Look, but at least you don't have to wait for conversions before viewing a movie file.


I'm still trying to figure out if Perian is letting QT 7 open the movies files that QT X isn't supporting. If so I'll leave it installed. It doesn't seem to be doing harm in any case.


Note that Perian is no longer being supported so a Mavericks version will not be forthcoming.


There is one advantage to using Quicktime X to convert files to .MOV files. Once you do so (and of course save the file) the file will open in Quick Look.

Please read my post in this thread: Perian is an QuickTime extension, QuickTime is only available for 32 bit applications and was replaced with "AV Foundation" for 64 bit applications.


In other words: Perian still works on Mavericks, but is only used if QuickTime is used. Which means: only for 32 bit applications like the old "QuickTime Player".


The new "QuickTime Player" on Mavericks is 64 bit and based on "AV Foundation" - this is the reason why it has to convert all videos which are not MP4, M4V, H264 (and may be some more formats). Same problem as with iOS (which uses "AV Foundation", too).


Apple should really rename the new "QuickTime Player" to "AV Foundation Player" because it has nothing to do with QuickTime. And people seems to be confused by its name.

I compared MP4 files that would preview with QuickLook and MP4 files that would NOT preview and found that the difference was that the MP4s that would not preview were compressed with Streaming Hints checked. I and others tested my theory and when the same file was compressed without Streaming Hints checked in Compressor then that MP4 would Finder preview with QuickLook (spacebar play). If the MP4 was compressed with Streaming Hints checked then it would not Finder preview with QuickLook. This is all under Mavericks of course. No problem with Hints-enabled MP4s under Mountain Lion.

After experiencing the problem in playing MP4 files with QT and reading all the posts here, I came up with a better solution. Instead of using QT to play MP4 files, I use Flip Player. To make it the default player, I associated the file with the player (in Finder, right click the file, select get info, and select Flip Player in Open With drop down menu.


If you do not have Flip Player, you can download from: http://download.cnet.com/Flip-Player/3000-13632_4-87679.html

OG,


The problem here is to make Quicklook works with all the video file.


If QuickTime X isn't working but there's alternatives like vlc, QuickTime 7 and many other video players...


We all need a solution for Quick-look being able to preview videos again....


Please apple !!!

I had removed Perian quite some time ago and I understood that the developers were retiring the project to work on other things.


The recent update to Mac OS X 10.9 prevented me from accessing AVIs through QuickTime Player (10.3), QuickTime Player 7 Pro (7.6.6) and Flip Player (3.2.1.2). All three were also unable to convert the AVI files.


On reinstalling Perian (1.2.3) I have now been able to view AVIs through all players and I am also able to convert them to other formats.


I'm taking this 'opportunity' to convert all AVI files to MOV format which I hope is a worthwhile move.


The fans are whirring!

Converting in Quicktime Player X (like it starts doing when opening an .avi, .flv...) would be a solution if these files wouldn't get 2 to 4 times bigger than the original file! :-(

Hope I'm not being patronising but I right-click my original file and at the bottom end of the drop-down menu I use 'Encode Selected Video Files'.


The available options give me all I need for relatively quick conversion without having the player running.


I've just done several hundred small AVI files to MOV and even using 1080p didn't cause too much increase in file size.


eg. 3.6MB to 4.8MB, 5.2MB to 5.9MB, 4.2MB to 5.8MB


Bigger, yes, but absolutely none of them were anywhere close to double.


The increases you are seeing would have definitely put me off!

You are looking for the fountain of youth with your plea for Apple to fix Quick Look. Apple couldn't care an ***. That's the nature of the company. It's purist... my way or the highway.


So look somewhere else for a solution.

I've just tried a flv-file from 305MB and converted it (the way you describe) at 480p and the outcome was an m4v from 658MB...

thomasselis:


Your experience is nothing new. I've belabored Apple in many previous posts that it does not do a good job of efficiently converting files to its favored format. Take for example converting Word documents to Pages. The result is about 2x bloat. So I am reluctant to be purely Apple when it comes to using its apps. I look at what does the job efficiently.

Wanya_23, the issue of QuickLook not working for the favorite file formats we use is that Apple didn't make them! As the OS gets more integratd with the 'cloud' and is online all the time, the functions that are nested inside the system will be more and more walled off.


The codecs to run most of the videos we get online now have their own security (like Flash which presents it's own headaches, hence Apple and Adobe getting spiky with each other after nearly 2 decades of playing together well) or are open source and prone to a faster upgrade cycle than Apple's security can vet for safety. (Just try and open an application that isn't from the App Store - I use an old version of iStat for my menus and in order to get MenuCracker to launch so iStat would run in the first place, I had to add it to a security exemption list!)


All of this 'not working' nonsense is Apple firming up internal security in the OS. Until Apple decides to incorporate some sort of a sandbox around video codecs through the QuickLook, don't hold your breath.


You'll just have to go back to the old fashioned way of watching videos..


In the QT 7 player.

Hi, quciktime cannot open AVI files, but after converting them to MOV, it can play the video. And here, to do the conversion, what we need is a AVI to MOV converter, this tool can help you convert avi files to mov freely.

So far, this is what I found out:


  1. You need a codec to use quick look for mp4 usually Perian, but this open project has stopped offering updates, so it won't fully work on Mavericks.
  2. Some mp4 files will play others will not, specifically the "H.264, AAC, Hint" seems to be the problem. The files whit out the "Hint" spec plays fine, you can check this whit the Get Info Command.
  3. If you open the mp4 file on Quick Time, its converted to a codec that can be use on quick look.


I'm sure that soon, some developer will provide a project similar to Perian. Until then you can also use Quick Time 7 to view the mp4 hinted files whit out conversion, but some HD videos will play slow or stop responding because the 32 bit compatibility.


So, in resume, install Perian, also install Flip4Mac and Quick Time 7, and specially, try to download or create not hinted mp4 movies.


Hope this to be useful.

QuickLook in Mavericks would appear to be using AV Foundation and therefore be limited to the Apple supported formats, i.e. not AVI.


Apple have deliberately chosen not to reveal to thirdparty developers how to write AV Foundation codecs becuse they want everyone to use H.264 etc. i.e. AV Foundation formats as their video format. If they allowed thirdparty codecs to support old formats then this would allow people to be lazy and leave their videos unconverted.


Why do Apple want people to only use the new(er) formats? Apart from making their code simpler, it allows Apple to optimise processing these handful of formats both for speed and power. Apparently Apple have provided a library called QTMovieModernizer which while it does not allow playing older formats does allow them to be converted. However from what people have been saying here it makes the files much bigger. There are plenty of thirdparty tools to convert formats many are free, and in some cases could do things more simply like taking an FLV containing H.264 and simply put it in a new MOV envelope without having to reconvert the H.264 video itself. In some cases VLC can do this for example.


In conclusion it would appear you have no chance of getting AVI etc. supported by QuickLook but by installing QuickTime Player 7 and Perian you can play them still.


It might be worth reading the following.


http://asciiwwdc.com/2013/sessions/606


Note: While I see Apple's reasoning I would still like AV Foundation to be able to support more codecs.


PS. In case you think it is any better on the Windows side of the fence, when Microsoft launched Windows7 they introduced Media Foundation as an intended replacement for DirectShow filters. This could be considered to be equivalent to Apple replacing QuickTime with AV Foundation. Whilst I believe Microsoft have released the details on how to write Media Foundation codecs, the reality is that practically zero have been written so far and we are now on Windows 8.1! It is still possible to use DirectShow filters in Windows Media Player (thankfully) and hence I can still use the Apple Lossless DirectShow filter to play my music files.

John Lockwood wrote:


Why do Apple want people to only use the new(er) formats? Apart from making their code simpler, it allows Apple to optimise processing these handful of formats both for speed and power.


Speed and power should be the same if the video is H264 and the container is AVI or MOV.


John Lockwood wrote:


Apparently Apple have provided a library called QTMovieModernizer which while it does not allow playing older formats does allow them to be converted.


1.) I have thousends of videos, some very short (no problem), some very long (time consuming).

2.) Every decoding and re-encoding - and this is what QTMovieModernizer does - means less quality.

3.) My camera records H264 in a AVI container. Apple's new strategy means to wait each time I want to edit a movie. If the movie is long, I can go to sleep and work the next morning?


John Lockwood wrote:


There are plenty of thirdparty tools to convert formats ... like taking an FLV containing H.264 and simply put it in a new MOV envelope without having to reconvert the H.264 video itself..


This would be helpful - may be some one should write a handy tool for this. I know VLC - but did not know that it can put H264 from AVI to MOV without de- and re-encoding. Any hints?

Not to be glib, but a QuickTime Pro key seems to stop the QTMovieModernizer from running.

I have yet to see this thing show it's head on my system and I have a Pro key - NONE of my videos are affected.


Deb.

Hi. Can anyone confirm what Deborah wrote? Specifically, her experience in owning QT Pro allowing her to avoid this God-forsaken ridiculous waste of my time moving backwards? This is the first thread I came across in what has become the beginning of my "Crusade", so I haven't had a chance to see if any other similar threads have produced a quick and easy fix.


If someone could please confirm what Deborah wrote earlier, please tell! I have no problem scrounging up the pennies in my Rainy Day fund and tossing them at this rotten apple- money comes and goes, but my time is the one resource that no one can return back to me.


Thanks!

Apparently if you use QuickTime Player 7.6.6 in Mavericks and have any required codecs installed and open the videos in QuickTime Player 7.6.6 then you can still play them as before without being nagged to convert them.


The issue only arises if you open them in QuickTime Player X.


Therefore for .avi, .wmv, .mkv, etc. i.e. non-Apple formats set them to always open in QuickTime Player 7.6.6


You can still use Perian with QuickTime Player 7.6.6 but not QuickTime Player X.

Hi. Can anyone confirm what Deborah wrote? Specifically, her experience in owning QT Pro allowing her to avoid this God-forsaken ridiculous waste of my time moving backwards? This is the first thread I came across in what has become the beginning of my "Crusade", so I haven't had a chance to see if any other similar threads have produced a quick and easy fix.


If someone could please confirm what Deborah wrote earlier, please tell! I have no problem scrounging up the pennies in my Rainy Day fund and tossing them at this rotten apple- money comes and goes, but my time is the one resource that no one can return back to me.

Not exactly sure which aspect you and/or Deb are referring to. As John indicated, QT 7 Pro continues to work normally under Mavericks as far as AVI playback is concerned. That is AVI, FLV, MKV, DV stream, and MOV fils containing AIC, Animation, or PNG encoded video. However, since MPEG Streamclip also performs normally, my assumption is that this is due to the QT classic 32-bit structure still embedded in the Mavericks OS and not due to the presence of the "Pro" key. (Unfortunately, if I remove my purchased "Pro" key, then QT reverts to my FCP "Pro" key and I am unwilling to uninstall that key just to test one possible interpretation of Deb's comment.) In short, neither the QT 7 Pro player nor the MPEG Streamclip media apps seem to be plagued by the QT X player's attempt to convert or not convert a particular compression format or compression format/file format combination—including formats like AIC in MOV, DV in DV, PNG in MOV, etc,


On the other hand if you are interpreting the comment to mean that the presence of a QT 7 "Pro" key will prevent QT X v10.3 from attempting to perform a conversion, then I would tend to disagree with that generalization. The only AVI file QT X v10.3 has not tried to convert only my system is one containing Motion JPEG video with DVI ADPCM audio—i.e., an old digital camera file someone sent me for analysis years ago which is still on on system. In addition, the question as to whether or not QT X v10.3 will "passthrough" a particular compression format also seems to depend on the container involved. Based on these two observations, it appears that the AVI container, in and of itself, is not what is forcing QT X v10.3 to transcode files since the container itself still seems to "QT" compatible.


Therefore, as John stated, the decesion as to whether or not to invest in a QT 7 Pro key really depends on the work flow you wish to adopt here. If all you want is playback, then the QT 7 player with the appropriate QT codec component configuration can play your files. If you also want conversion and some limited editing features, then install the free MPEG Streamclip app along with the required codec components that work for the QT 7 app. But, if you require a more advanced conversion, compositing, and masking workflow along with access to built-in editing filters, then by all means go with a QT 7 "Pro" key here.


User uploaded file

Not sure if this has already been mentioned, but apparently due to issues with sandboxing (now required for apps offered in the App Store) MplayerX is discontinuing offing its latest versions through the App Store. I just tried using the version of MplayerX in the App Store and it crashes every time. I am about to test the latest MplayerX binary from the developer's website. You can read the developer's assessment here: http://mplayerx.org/leave-mas.html

I will chime in with previous comments in saying that it is unacceptable for Quicktime to force file format conversion. Also, I am finding that some mpeg4 files neither play or convert. They are treated as unreadable. Furthermore, an mpg video file plays the video portion, but I get no audio!


This is nuts!

We did not even try to offer our applications (nessMediaCenter, nessViewer) in the App Store because of sandboxing. Both applications need free access to folders - for example the media server (which allows it to stream media to nessViewer for iOS) needs access to the folders the user adds and all of its subfolders. And this is impossible. Same for the media center, which needs access to the iPhoto & iTunes library and folders like the picture & movie folder (and all of its subfolders).


As already mentioned, it is not QuickTime which force file format conversion, but AV Foundation. AV Foundation comes from iOS and it can read and play only a few video formats.


But conversion is not the only problem. If you want to edit a movie (cut, copy, paste), it is much more complicated (or even impossible) with the new "QuickTime Player" (which is based on AV Foundation). We are working since Mac OS X 10.7 on 64 bit versions of our applications to bring back the simplicity of the old "QuickTime Player" and FrontRow. We still hope that Apple will extend AV Foundation and its supported movie formats, but guess that this will not happen.


One reason for AV Foundation on Mac to support only MPEG4 and H264 might be iCloud - it makes no sense to synchronize movies to iOS if iOS can not play these movies.

One reason for AV Foundation on Mac to support only MPEG4 and H264 might be iCloud - it makes no sense to synchronize movies to iOS if iOS can not play these movies.

I think you might be right with that. Which leads me to the conclusion that Apple is forcing us to use iCloud, whether we like it or not (synching Calendars and Contacts from iPhone to your Mac is not possible anymore without iCloud – before Mavericks, you could do it by USB-cable).


What about those people who do not want to sychronize movies on all of their devices? Who want to keep part of their files (such as movies in older codecs) just on the mac and want to use them as before?? Why is Apple not giving us a choice?

Jon Walker,


I appreciate the effort you put in your post, which I found informative and helpful. Just to be clear, it was never my intention for anyone to put Deborah's experience to the test and delete any app or program, especially one that has been paid for!


Not to personalize this as every user's experience is unique, I believe I am one that others can relate to. Just to break it down:


Experienced Mac user for several years

Need-to-know basis for learning video formats and editing (learned just enough to make things play)

Pre-Mav:

Installed Perian, Flip4Mac, ffmpeg

Played most videos using QT X

Played the few that didn't with VLC

If the rare conversion was necessary, MPEG Streamclip


To be brutally honest, I care nothing for understanding the logic and reasonings of Apple's decisions (as of late, especially), and leave that discussion for the more intellectual of our community.


The search is for the easiest and quickest work around fix, allowing both:

1. QT to stop converting automatically nearly every video opened, and

2. Return previewing functionality via Quicklook (spacebar play), as well as playing the video in the preview pane of Finder windows

3. Very basic video editing functions, like those found in QT (clip, split, etc.) - but easily given up for the first two goals


From your post and related discussion, it appears the options thus far are:

1. Use the older QT 7 (32-bit) for playback, no need for installation of any additional apps/codecs than already was installed, understanding the possibility of some performance issues (slow, laggy, choppy playback, delay, unresponsive/crashing of app); no Quicklook functionality or Finder preview

2. Convert all videos, whether in batches prior to playback or as a single conversion on a needed basis, understanding the possibility for converted formats inflating to a minimal increase in size, to more than double the original size (depending on containers and such); Quicklook/Finder previewing functionality restored for converted videos; extremely time- and CPU-resource demanding

3. Reassign all video formats to be played strictly using VLC, MPEG Streamclip, and possibly other 3rd-party apps, or a combination thereof; no Finder/Quicklook functionality

4. Purchase a key for QT 7 Pro; practically no forced conversion and playback functionality restored with no real added performance issues, plus more video editing options; understanding monetary cost and possible discontinuing support, Finder/Preview functionality unknown?

5. Revert the OS to a state prior to updating to Maverick OS using a saved previous session backed-up via Time Machine, requiring backing-up of the system prior to the update


Are those the main options? Depending on whether or not I can restore Finder/Quicklook previewing functionality with a QT 7 Pro key, I have what I need to decide my next step.


I apologize for the long post... in my attempt to help others in a similar situation as myself, and trying to do so typing on an iPhone, I might have produced a hard read.


Thank you, Jon (and John), and anyone else for your time!


Michael

Michael.. don't bother with a Pro key. I was throwing out ideas before I had sussed out that it was in point of fact QuickTime Player 7.6.6 that is the solution, and NOT the Pro key itself.


I've NEVER liked or used the QTX and from Day 1 just installed the QuickTime 7 and put in my Pro key.


To get around al the reconversion nonsense and have the widest support for all the old file formats you use, here is a cut-and-paste of the list I've compiled - with installation instructions - to get everything running.


The QuickTimePlayer X that comes with your system is trying to reformat - there is NO way to get around it as the instructions are nested down in the libraries for the application - in the QTKit.framework. It's an instruction-set that you can't get out unless you know how to program code. (I think it's in Objective C)


With that as a given, what is left to do is download and use the last available version of QuickTime Player 7 and get the codec packs you need - all of this is the 32-bit code and it's days ARE numbered so fair warning.


Here is the quick list I've built as a workaround to keep your files unsullied.



Start with QT 7.6.6. - http://support.apple.com/kb/DL923


Get Perian, and install it. - http://perian.org


then VLC, - http://videolan.org


DivX - http://divx.com - and the


Flip4Mac package from Telestream - http://www.telestream.net/flip4mac/


A52/AC3 downloader: https://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/21875/a52codec - In this installer package there is an audio A52Codec.component. DO NOT USE IT! Throw it out and use the one that is linked below.



This is what I've put into my system and so far I've gotten every file to run fine, even my oldest videos.


These are codecs you should see.


In System/Library/QuickTime

AppleIntermediateCodec.component

AppleMPEG2Codec.component* (*optional if you've bought it)

DivX Decoder.component

Flip4Mac WMV Advanced.component

Flip4Mac WMV Export.component

Flip4Mac WMV Import.component


In your Home/Library/QuickTime/

AC3MovieImport.component (you may or may not want this component, in some instances it causes conflicts. In my system, it doesn't. Who knows why? I don't.)

Perian.component


For AC3 sound that is in most .mkv files, you need the A52Codec.component, this is the one you want, here:https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/34821905/A52Codec.component.zip - unzip the file and put the component into the System/Library/Audio/Plug-ins/Components


Go back to your Perian settings and in the Audio Output button, set it to 'Multi Channel Sound' - Ignore the message Perian puts up and select it.


By doing a 'Get Info' on your files and where it says 'Open With' - default them to the QuickTime 7 program. Perian no longer will work with QuickTime Player so you must have QT 7.6.6 and set it so it is the default for all the filetypes you use.


It works perfectly with QT7. So far I've gotten ALL my old videos to play.


.avi, .mov (with the AC3 sound), .wmv, .flv, .mp4 and .m4v. all run fine as do all the older formats.


Deb.

Are those the main options? Depending on whether or not I can restore Finder/Quicklook previewing functionality with a QT 7 Pro key, I have what I need to decide my next step.

Not quite as stated.


1) Use of QT 7 (classic 32-bit QT structure embed) may require additional codecs or file support to handle file/compression types not supported but the basic host OS codec component configuration. To actively use (encode) legacy compression formats turned off by default under Mac OS X v10.7, v10.8, and/or v10.9 will require the user to manually re-activate the desired codecs. Performance issues normally depend on the harware capabilities, compression formats involved, and/or encode settings used to create the files. (E.g., it is hard to smoothly play a file having a data rate greater than the throughput of your hard drive or greater than your media player can render without droping frames.)


2) Agree.


3) Basically agree but stress that QL Finder/preview remains whatever the host OS supports—something that remains to be fully mapped under Mavericks. (E.g., I have a Motion JPEG/DVI ADPCM AVI file that is still compatible with QT X playback and QL Finder/Preview under Mavericks. However, this appears to be an exception to the general rule for file content support under this OS release.)


4) QT 7 Player and QT 7 Player Pro playback capabilities are the same—only dependent on the system's QT codec component configuration. Keying the app for "Pro" use has no effect on performance issues or QL Finder/Preview cabilities. It is however, the only standalone, non-professional video editing utility with track level compositing and masking capabilities built in so I consider it well worth the price until such time as support may be discontinued.


5) Would generally agree with your statement here but personally prefer creating pristine boot drives and either reinstalling or migrating apps as needed. (I.e. I normally keep at least two standalone external drives with basic OS software for current, as well as, previous major Mac OS in case of catastrophic main startup drive failure, and bare drives with older major Mac OS versions for use in a removable HD case for testing purposes, as well as, four RAID assemblies totalling 41 TBs for content/project storage which represents my personal home, non-business system. It may sound like overkill, but I have a basic philosophy that states that if anything bad can happen, it will, and usually at the worst possible time.)


User uploaded file

It may sound like overkill, but I have a basic philosophy that states that if anything bad can happen, it will, and usually at the worst possible time.


User uploaded file

LOL! Oh do we think on the same lines!


Though not as much data, I still have many, many escape options available. As it stands, this latest upgrade was put on my uber-partitioned MacBook Pro - and am not at all interested in "keeping up with the Jobses" to the point where certain wired functionality is lost to the 'cloud'.


Suffice it to say, the Mavericks upgrade was an interesting side diversion and yep, call me unimpressed as it's offering less and less that is relevant to my needs out of a computer.


(I am a digital artist and work with a photographer and a videographer)


I'll toss out what help I can, but I can see my days are numbered with Mac OS if it continues to expect or *insist* that users live on social networks or store their personal data on 'clouds' - which at a time in the not-too-distant future may very well present too much of a fat, juicy target for inspired hackers to resist.


Yeahhhh.. I don't think I'll be putting anything up there..


At the point where I still cannot outdraw a 7 year old MacPro with a Wacom attached to it, why jump through the hoops or dance to Apple's tune on this? We're at the cusp of what I see will be many profound structural changes to what computing is and how users interact with their devices and even whether they'll always have access to their data.


Everyone is going this way, not just Apple and as vjPulp asked, why they are pushing this on users.. simply it is because for many - those who HAVE to 'keep up' - well, they *can* push - and that is the majority of users that just want their shiny toys to bring them the stock reports or weather or their grandkids pictures.


The pro user/content creators aren't Apple's targets anymore - if they ever really were.


I'm quite content to work on my now 7 year old relic and stay with a fully functional Snow Leopard. (Heck, I even worked out with the xCode Tools how to install Sun Java..)


For now, Mavericks.. is well.. meh, with a boatload of issues for content production that doesn't bode well in the short term.


Regards,

It´s frustrating! Apple forces me to use a non-Apple-product to play avi or mov! It´s possible to use QT7, but why should I? Perhaps in some weeks or months Apple decides to change the codecs for QT7 as well??? Therefor it´s better to use immidiately other software to play that movies.

(Chuckling with a smile to match...) We do think quite alike!

I'll toss out what help I can, but I can see my days are numbered with Mac OS if it continues to expect or *insist* that users live on social networks or store their personal data on 'clouds' - which at a time in the not-too-distant future may very well present too much of a fat, juicy target for inspired hackers to resist.

Totally agree. Decided to opt out on my own with the demise of MobileMe. Purchased a server configured MacMini and my own domain name for personal content I didn't mind exposing to the public via the internet and have been satisfied ever since. Am now testing a LaCie 3 TB CloudBox for password protected content area shared exclusivly between local user group members. (Not as happy with this as it is much slower but does provide dedicated plug-in and play, bi-directional browser access to non-DropBox user group members while remaining under my own physical control.) As to "fat, jucy targets," another philosophical "rule of thumb" is to never put anything on a computer or storage device that can't be disconnected from the internet, can't be replaced, or you can't afford to have compromised.


User uploaded file

For those complainers,


If you don't like what Apple has done/is doing/would like to do, quit complaining and move on to other platforms. And I wish you all the luck in the world.


There are too many who complain and holler that Apple is doing this or doing that. Remember, Apple is doing what it considers is good for the many. It couldn't care less about your piddling singular existence.


So for those who think that digging deeper into the nuances of a certain app, as many have shown in this particular app forum, just to sound off as very knowledgeable to others who have a desire to look for problem solutions, we don't need you in this forum. Get a life. You are just wasting good space. We need people who can provide solutions and work-arounds to specific problems.

This is truly disgraceful from Apple. I thought breaking Preview was one thing but now Apple are taking a leaf out of Win"those" book!

On Windows 8 X64 bit for example you cannot see thumbnail previews for any Adobe Products anymore unless you now BUY an app that was previously free in Windows 7 to render them - ie Mystic Thumbs! Pretty Bad......
On Mac however if you are into making movies, editing etc thumb views are invaluabe and a neccessity... Lack of them is like a blindfold to visual artists!
Not only have apple not built this ability into the operating system but now they have changed the architecture so we cannot now avail of the solution previously employed...(ie the now similarly defunct Perian... and flv.qlgenerator).

Please apple - rethink this... a huge part of your loyal customer fanbase are Visual Artists, designers and Movie makers.. You are now taking away our toys... soon there will be nobody interested in designing anymore... then...good luck to your iOS devices as they too will be too drab to entice buyers anymore!
I can live without Quick Look Previews perhaps,,, but thumbnail previews....most definitely not!

ANOTHER GLICH


Ok the mac sometimes when it converts .mov files.


After it converts them some of the thumb nails are missing you have to open the file then the thumb nail appers.


If you then open finder and locate the files you will see once again the thumb nails are missing on some of the nails.

You have to open the files then close them to keep the thumb nails.


IF YOUR MAC HANGS AND YOU CANT GET FORCE QUIT TO WORK BECAUSE THE MAC IS IN THINK MODE OR WHATEVER THIS IS A FUNNY WORK AROUND..

IF YOU HAVE DUAL MONITORS YOU CAN GOTO THE APPLE LOGO ON THE SECOND SCREEN AND FORCE QUIT FROM THERE...........


AS I SAID BEFORE THE BEGGINING IF THE END.........

Use the keys to get Force Quit window up - they are 'command'+'option'+'escape' and it will show.


As to the Mavericks re-encoding - I am not sure where it is, as my main computer is still running Snow Leopard, (and I smack down HARD the QTX on my laptop that I did upgrade, and rolled back to QT 7.6.6 and put in my Pro key) but when the videos go to re-encode, if you make the settings for the conversion to 'pass-through' it doesn't resize the file, it merely puts the correct 'file flags' or some such bit of data on the container - the .mov or .mp4 that the movie is in..


If you dig around, you can find the exact directions, I think they are buried down in this thread.

Use the keys to get Force Quit window up - they are 'command'+'option'+'escape' and it will show.

Or "C 00004000 ommand+Option+Q" to close the QT X app and empty any open player windows and/or conversion in progress.



As to the Mavericks re-encoding - I am not sure where it is...

If referring to the actual converter routine, it appears to now be part in the "Moderizer" embedded at the system level for shared use by apps like QT X, as well as, being independently accessible as a Finder service under Mavericks.


User uploaded file

Ah, okay. I think I'll dig out an old file and put it through the QTX ringer and play with the thing.


All in all, I still find most of my time is using the MacBookPro under Snow Leopard.


I just cannot muster the interest to even learn the ins and outs of Mavericks, it has so little that is of actual use for my needs. More's the pity, as I spend a lot of time fixing what it's broken and finding workarounds for the customers I troubleshoot for.

I just cannot muster the interest to even learn the ins and outs of Mavericks, it has so little that is of actual use for my needs. More's the pity, as I spend a lot of time fixing what it's broken and finding workarounds for the customers I troubleshoot for.

While I consider it interesting to learn about QT X v10.3 and Mavericks itself, like you, I have been and am still using QT 7 Pro v7.6.6 as my default QT player for Snow Leopard, Lion, Mountain Lion and Mavericks and simply don't understand why so many users don't keep both installed and simply use whichever best supports the particular file they want to play at any given time. (I.e., of the approximately 26 TBs of videos currently in my personal library, less than 10 TBs are iTunes managed (QT X v10.3 compatible) while the rest are mostly in QT X v10.3 playback incompatible formats best played using VLC or QT 7 with only about 0.01% in various AVI formats of which about half remain QT X v10.3 compatible since they are MJPEG/PCM AVI files.) For me, it is the results that count and using the right tool for a job assures those results.


User uploaded file

Thanks Jon Walker.


You've proved my point. you've got different programs to open certain types of files.


You've download quicktime 7 or what ever to open files that could be opened by a apple computer before mavericks upgrades


You've downloaded VLC player to play certain other types of files.


The apple computer today after a mavericks upgrade does not "just work"


Apple are moving away from supporting certain formats so they can no longer be played on a mac, but it was this ability to play other formats which made people turn to apple in the first place.


You now have to download other programs to play basic files.....WHY?


Its not like the old days when memory cost alot and was very small...

Why not add as many programs or codecs into a system as possible as standard...


And don't say it's not possible because people are going to do it anyway, they are going to go onto the iternet and get VLC and other programs to get there stuff working - the programs are free anyway.......


So why not just include it at the start.....

I think that it's as Apple is playing the proprietary format game.. as in when you see that iTunes is defaulted to convert CD's to AAC instead of the wider-use .mp3 format - you have to change that setting in the preferences.


Every format that Apple computers includes support for is one more licensing fee they have to pay - hence the departure of Rosetta - that was heavily licensed to the owner of the technology, so once they got far enough away from the Power PC architecture, they kicked it to the curb. (also why I'm STILL using Snow Leopard.)


So now Apple is trying to set their own formats out to play well with their ARM chips on their mobile iThings and most of the A/V code is now deprecated to third-party status.


If you read the tech business papers, there is a LOT of wrangling over various file formats and little of what we think of as 'standard' is actually open source. It all has in one way or another, to be paid for if it is included in an OS.


Mavericks was free, so that right there should tell you it's filled *mostly* with Apple's proprietary code. They make enough on the hardware to not need to skive users for the OS, esp. so if it gives them the ability to move the user-base to their walled-off environment.


As a business decision, I see it.


As a consumer and end-user of the product, I'm.. well.. just blaaah about it all.

It's not only the proprietary format game, but also the iCloud game, as I explained in previous post: Apple wants that every file you load in your computer can be uploaded to iCloud and downloaded and played on an iPhone or iPad. And those cannot play, f.ex., DivX or Xvid or MKV by default, so they have to be converted to a compatible format, .MOV.


And Apple doesn't have to pay any licenses or copy rights for, f.ex., MKV or Xvid, so that's not the problem, at least on these formats.


Saluditos,


Ferrán.

OK if its about the cloud then why would apple first take a video file which is say 32.2mb at the start. Buy converting this to play on an apple mac before mavericks installed increased the file size to 82.6mb. After mavericks installed another conversion process was required which increased the size to 175.9 mb almost six times the original file size, but remember "its the same video, no increase in resolution.

Six times the size in the cloud means six times the download time....


Anyway I know its not the right thread but I think I should mention this.


On mavericks if you have a list of files in a folder and you want to delete some be carefull


The thumb nail "preview" in the cover flow is not always the file that you have highlighted below.


Mavericks has a problem on updating the thumbnail.


You can fix this by going to view button and re-arranging the view agian. this will update the images assossiated with the file.


Talk about appaling pre-testing FINDER...before release.....

If dudexxx is talking about a file size like 32 MB, then - in my opionion - it is worth to take a look at the history and the current state.


Apple developed QuickTime, QuickTime authoring and QuickTime VR fo 00004000 r professional and consumer market - success? Not really. Just take a look at millions of (un-synchronized) movies - even nowadays.


And then they developed iOS (devices) - success? Yes!


Now there is a big fight between the companies who will be the leader in tablet & mobil and computer environment. If you think of millions of users who have these devices - how many have a computer?


Apple is a company, sorry for this useless comment. But times are changing. Now it is about

1.) Shoot a short video with your tablet & mobil device.

2.) Trim a little bit if necessary. But only if you have time for this... not really a big interesting point.

3.) But then - and this is the major point - upload it! Be visible, join community, use services like iCloud. Do not make your data private! Join it!


If I take a look at the updates since 10.7 then I do not see anything usefull. May be I missed something, but I see "only" upgrades to support online services. And to adapt Mac OS X to iOS.


To come back to the point of dudexxx: you are an unusual user. And you do not bring profit, but trouble.

1.) You have movie files which must be converted. As someone said: millions of users have only MPEG4 or H.264 movie files. And must not convert any movie. And even if they have to: where is the problem?

2.) Stop talking about problems. Just join & like Apple's plan. If you don't: leave it.

3.) If you are inbetween then you could use open source software like VLC. And please do not ask why to buy expensive Apple hardware if you use open source software which can be used on any platform (except iOS devices, of course).


Please do not misunderstand me: I would agree to your point of view. But you (and me) are not the people who buy a new iPhone every year (or even less).


And to come back to the original question: this questions is solved. Just install the old QuickTime (and may be extensions like Perian) and everything is working. We should proceed this discussion with the next version of Mac OS X where Apple might not support QuickTime for 32 bit.

Thanks Jon Walker.


You've proved my point. you've got different programs to open certain types of files.

You shouldn't thank me too soon since you are totally missing my point. Previously, the embedded multimedia structure consisted of what might be called a dual 64-bit and a 32-bit QuickTime structure. On the other hand, Mavericks seems to have two separate multimedia structures—the AVFoundation/Moderizer/Convert system-wide shared structure that supports QT X based applications, as well as the Finder and the other is the 32-bit QuickTime structure that still supports QuickTime based applications like the QT 7 Player/QT 7 Pro Players. I.e, the 64-bit QT structure no longer exists. Your argument appears falacious since it is based on the assumption that the 64-bit "QuickTime" still exists under Mavericks and and you insist on using "the wrong tool" for your content playback. To me, this seems tantamount to a person being given a car with a diesel engine, then complaining that it doesn't run on gasoline and insisting the provider take back the vehicle and replace the engine before you will accept the gift.



You've download quicktime 7 or what ever to open files that could be opened by a apple computer before mavericks upgrades

Actually, you are mistaken here also. QT 7 Pro was installed on my Leopard system before I upgraded to Snow Leopard. In fact, I continued to find the app so useful—especially under Lion when Apple turned for the legacy codecs, that I decided to install it on the iMac when I purchased it and migrated the FCP Suite to the new system, which, of course, automtically keyed the the QT 7 v7.6.6 Player for "Pro" use, allowing me to finally use the free key rather than the purchased key which I left on the old system when I gave it to my wife Your main problem is that you seem to insisting that QT X v10.3 should be a "universal" media player capable of handling any and all forms of compressed data. THERE IS NO SUCH ANIMAL! If you thouroughly test any given media player app, sooner or later you will find there is something that it cannot handle. So, yes, I do have QT 7 v7.6.6 Pro still installed on my Mavericks system because it's one of many possible "right tools" for the playback of certain files and the "right tool" for track-level editing, masking. and/or application of filters still available under Mavericks. I also have MPEG Streamclip installed because it is a better tool to quickly merging multiple files using a simple "drag 'n drop" workflow whereas QT 7 or QT X would simply open multiple player windows.



You've downloaded VLC player to play certain other types of files.

This is also true for many reasons. Primarily, I use the MKV file container for the storage of Blu-ray encoded content and have made VLC the default player for this combination of compressed data and file container. Since it takes QT 7 forever to open and read 20, 30, or 40 GB files to find he valid EOF marker before attemptin to play the file (which both QT X v10.3 and QT 7 v7.6.6 do poorly), it only seemed logical to use "a better tool" for such playback. In addition, the Apple DVD player no konger seems to like my "image" DVD files but VLC has no problem with them. Unfortunately, VLC doesn't handle to all BD content—especially 1080i VC-1 encoded discs, so I also have a dedicated software BD media player installed for BD playback directly from the disc. So, yes, I do have a multitude of media players installed on my system because each has capabilities that may or may not be shared by the others. Or as I attempted to explain previously, I have adopted a philosophy of using "the right tool of the right job" while you you keep insisting that QT X v10.3 is "the correct tool" for you to use whether or not it is still actually programmed to support the files you want to play.


The apple computer today after a mavericks upgrade does not "just work"


You seem to be under the misconception that, in an age of techical consolidation and specializatiio, Apple has choosen to "buck current trends" and devote its expertise to the development of a universal multimedia player that supports heretofore unsupported codec components, as well as, disregarding the obvious consolidation of their own natively supported codecs. Each of the last three operating system upgrades clearly point in the opposite direction no matter how hard to choose to ignore the facts that are staring you in the face.. Software seldom works corectly if you use it incorectly. If you wish to play files supported by the AVFoundation, then use QT X v10.3 under Mavericks. If you wish to play files supported by the embedded QT structure, then use the QT 7 v7.6.6 Player. Apple has prvided a workflow that still works. Whether or not you use is strictly up to you.



Apple are moving away from supporting certain formats so they can no longer be played on a mac, but it was this ability to play other formats which made people turn to apple in the first place.

More obfuscations based on a lack of research, lack of user testing, and HOW YOU THINK QTX v10.3 should work rather than how it actually does work in reality. Your statement might have more weight if you specified the compression formats to which you are referring. Many/most AVIs require third-party support for proper playack Such files may never have been supported by Apple or may have been dropped by their distributer back as far a OS 8 when they decided to develope their own, more modern codecs. (I still miss the MPEG-1 compression codec auto-installed by Toast a decade or more ago but which ws automatically deleted when the system no longeer would support it under the newer OSs and/or QT "Pro" app Pro versions.



You now have to download other programs to play basic files.....WHY?

Same reason as always.. You must play the file in an app that supports both "the current form of data contained in the file" and uses a file type that is that is current;y compatible with the player you are using—not an app that used to play it under last operating system system or the system before that.



Its not like the old days when memory cost alot and was very small...

Why not add as many programs or codecs into a system as possible as standard...

Again, what does this mean to you? Are you suggesting that Apple steal and make use of proprietary technogy as in the case that Apple just won.? While Windows, DivX, XviD, 3ivX, the latest Sorrenson codecs, Flash, etc. are now being sold directly by Mac users (if still supported). But why, pray tell, would anyone take on the headack of supportig someone else's proprietary or non-public domain codec components, adapt them to use on the Mac, and then wait around for the federal governmnet to fine them. (Sounds like sombody would have to be pretty dense to do this. (Perhaps you would like to take on this job?) Frankly, I am more concerned the consolidation of the Apple Animation and AIC, DV, etc., stream codecs which still seem to be supported by iMovie (if I choose tto use it). Luckily I switched to an HDV camcorter several years ago so to aerve as my lo low-efficiency archive format directly from my camcorder and am not really interested in moving to super-high compression format like AVCHD. (Again, this is a personal choice for me and you are welcome to use whatever codecs and playyou prefer.)



And don't say it's not possible because people are going to do it anyway, they are going to go onto the iternet and get VLC and other programs to get there stuff working - the programs are free anyway.......

I wouldn't think of it. Many uers (since the days of the Fifth Generayion iPod) h 00004000 ave uswd apps and utilities to try an e,bed headers that will allow you to play non-standard frofil, level, and feature combinations. You may get way with iy for a while. bu sooner or later Aplple may slasm this door in your facwe with a security update.


So why not just include it at the start.....


You really should look into the legal ramificaions of your suggestions. On 11/21/13, Apple was awarded $290.45 million dollars from Samsung in the latest parent litigation retrail. (Apple asked for $397.8 million but Samsumng only offered $52.7 million) after they initially lost awrderd a $600 millilion dollars settlement to Apple by the District last Maech. She later ruled that there were some errors in calculating the $600 million dollar award., and ordered a retrail. So how much should Apple put you down for Apple's defense andor the ultimate fine if Apple should follow your suggestions?


User uploaded file

Mavericks seems to have two separate multimedia structures—the AVFoundation/Moderizer/Convert system-wide shared structure that supports QT X based applications, as well as the Finder and the other is the 32-bit QuickTime structure that still supports QuickTime based applications like the QT 7 Player/QT 7 Pro Players

I am astonished - because many people did complain that the Finder does not have a 32-bit QuickTime structure now with Mavericks and thereby the Finder can not show incompatible movies with QuickLook. Did I miss anything?


May be you mean the operation system which can emulate 32 bit routines?

the 64-bit QT structure no longer exists

It did never exist, not "no longer"!

To me, this seems tantamount to a person being given a car with a diesel engine, then complaining that it doesn't run on gasoline and insisting the provider take back the vehicle and replace the engine before you will accept the gift.

Great example! Remembers me with something Mr. Gates tried to mention: http://mistupid.com/jokes/msvgm.htm. Long ago! And still a running gag...

Your main problem is that you seem to insisting that QT X v10.3 should be a "universal" media player capable of handling any and all forms of compressed data. THERE IS NO SUCH ANIMAL!

Yes, there were and still is such an animal. It is called QuickTime (32 bit) with Perian and WMV as extension. It is an animal - eating (aka playing) "everything".

If you thouroughly test any given media player app, sooner or later you will find there is something that it cannot handle

Yes, of course. Even VLC sometimes failes to play movies and hangs. One reason for me to prefer the old QT Player (or applications based on old QT). Never had these problems...

the Apple DVD player no konger seems to like my "image" DVD files but VLC has no problem with them. Unfortunately, VLC doesn't handle to all BD content—especially 1080i VC-1 encoded discs, so I also have a dedicated software BD media player installed for BD playback directly from the disc. So, yes, I do have a multitude of media players installed on my system because each has capabilities that may or may not be shared by the others.

You are a lucky user. And you explained this to your family? "Please learn how to handle different movie types?" Lucky one! My family told me to trash that idea. They told me: one application to launch any movie...

while you keep insisting that QT X v10.3 is "the correct tool" for you to use whether or not it is still actually programmed to support the files you want to play.

And this is the current state for millions of users. How many people have the problems you have? Blu-ray, but no AVI files?

If you wish to play files supported by the AVFoundation, then use QT X v10.3 under Mavericks. If you wish to play files supported by the embedded QT structure, then use the QT 7 v7.6.6 Player. Apple has prvided a workflow that still works. Whether or not you use is strictly up to you.

Correct - and thereby the original question is solved. Until Apple offers a new Mac OS X version and will not support 32-bit (QuickTime).

Your statement might have more weight if you specified the compression formats to which you are referring.

This has been ask before - and someone posted a list of incompatible formats. Quite long in opposite to the compatible formats...

Such files may never have been supported by Apple

This argument has been said over and over again: BUT Apple made QT open by offering the extension feature…

more modern codecs

As who decides? Apple? If you ask people for making a list of compression formats, would you please make a list for us which codecs are modern and why? For the next 2 years, please. May be I convert all my movies as Apple likes now - and then in 2 years there is a new - more modern codec - and Apple does not like it.


In the past, QT was extendible. But now it is Apple who decides - this is the point for me.

MPEG-1… which ws automatically deleted when the system no longeer would support it under the newer OSs app Pro versions

I am surprised: MPEG-1 is not supported anymore? I can still play it with QuickTime 32 bit and the installed extensions.

You may get way with iy for a while. bu sooner or later Aplple may slasm this door in your facwe with a security update.

Yes, indeed. Be prepared that Apple will close doors. As I said: join it & like it - or leave it.

The original questions, asked by GalaxieMusique, was how to prevent conversion. This question is solved: just install the old QuickTime and may be some extensions (Perian and WMV), and everything works as before.


Okay - not everything. May be some features are lost (QuickLook?).


And then there is a more or less "emotional" discussion what Apple did in the past, what they are doing now and what they might do in the future.


Apple developed a very "rich" technology called QuickTime. This technology was open minded: other developers and companies were able to extend this technology by their own codecs. One example is Flip4Mac from Microsoft (WMV), another is Perian or DivX.


Many years ago we decided to develop our applications based on Apple technology aka QuickTime. There were a discussion if another solution would be to use open source movie playback, but we liked the idea to develop applications which are based on system technology.


We liked Front Row, Preview, DVD Player and QuickTime Pro - and the idea was to develop an application which has all these features in one application - plus some extra features we were (and are) missing.


Now Apple decided to deprecate QuickTime and to prefer "AV Foundation". QuickTime is very old - so the idea to refresh it and develop a new framework is a good idea.


With Mavericks, our 64 bit applications can now even analyse for the first time if a movie is compatible or not - and can offer the conversion. This was impossible before.


So far so good. What we do not like: downgrading a Apple computer to features well known from iOS. With AV Foundation on Mac OS X there are currently some major downgrades:


1.) With QuickTime, it was possible to copy a selection of a movie (or a track) and to paste this into a new movie. With AV Foundation, this is imposssible. Of course, several movie files can be joined and then parts can be deleted. But even if this is workaround, there are still some problems (or may be better called less options). QuickTime Pro users will see this problem...

2.) With QuickTime, it was possible to export / convert movies with very detailed parameters. With AV Foundation, there are only a few parameters. One reason why converting movies increases file size to 1/3 to triple.


These are two reasons why we still prefer our 32 bit applications, but have the 64 bit applications as options for the future.


If we think about Apple, who needed 3 Mac OS X versions (10.7 to 10.9) to develop something like QTMovieModernizer to recognize and convert movies, then we still hope that Apple will listen to this (and many other) discussion and will extend AV Foundation.


So we would like to suggest: please calm down and wait for new features Apple will bring. This is what they did for so many years...

I am astonished - because many people did complain that the Finder does not have a 32-bit QuickTime structure now with Mavericks and thereby the Finder can not show incompatible movies with QuickLook. Did I miss anything?


May be you mean the operation system which can emulate 32 bit routines?

I don't know about your system but the QT 7/QT 7 Pro app on my system under Mavericks is still a 32-bit app:


User uploaded file

As to QL, I said nothing about it. And, yes, you still seem to be missing the fact that it is a technology related to but separate from QT.



It did never exist, not "no longer"!

How strang 00004000 e! My Snow Leopard (pre-AVFoundation) system still insistes that that the QT X v10.0 player is a 64-bit app supported by a 64-bit embeded structure just as QT X v10.3 remains a 64-bit app as supported by the 64-bit AVFoundation.



Yes, there were and still is such an animal. It is called QuickTime (32 bit) with Perian and WMV as extension. It is an animal - eating (aka playing) "everything".

Didn't you just get through telling me there was no shich thing as a 32-bit version of QT a few paragraphs ago? Also, as far as I know no Indeo codec has been availal for use with any Mac OS X system configuration. Also, while QT plus Flip4Mac does support 1080i VC-1 playback, it does not do so whithout superimposing a "Windows Media" icon on the playback display—just two examples of an animal that does not "eat everything" as you seem to imply.



Yes, of course. Even VLC sometimes failes to play movies and hangs. One reason for me to prefer the old QT Player (or applications based on old QT). Never had these problems...

I suggest you expand your "old QT Player" test criteria and revise your statement.



You are a lucky user. And you explained this to your family? "Please learn how to handle different movie types?" Lucky one! My family told me to trash that idea. They told me: one application to launch any movie...

Sorry, I fail to understand the point you are try to make here. My point was that I require a vast number tools to best analyze and process content. Perhaps your needs are much more modest than mine or you need to explain the complexities involved to your family in better terms.



And this is the current state for millions of users. How many people have the problems you have? Blu-ray, but no AVI files?

Once again, what is your point? I consider Blu-ray a much more modern tecnology than AVI files using legacy, proprietary, or hybrid/non-standard codecs in a container requiring patches work properly. As to AVI files, they represent only a very small and somewhat limited facit of all possible forms of multimedia and, while I personally do not often create AVI content, I do perform problem analysis for others. As to millions of users, where are they? I only see a small number of very vocal AVI users who either do not create their own AVI files or are actually Windows users who for some inexplicable reason are using a Mac platform.



Correct - and thereby the original question is solved. Until Apple offers a new Mac OS X version and will not support 32-bit (QuickTime).

And so your argument now shifts to hypotheticals rather than facts. So what if it does happen? I merely replace QT 7 with VLC as my default media player for AVI files, use HandBreak as my default conversion app and continue with my current workflows—both of which are apps already installed on and in use on my Mavericks system and which employ codec packages that are independent of QT and the operating system. Oh, my... so many decisions and so little time to make them. But then, I am getting ahead of myself aren't I? As an elderly retired person I find it is often a waste my time to speculate on what may happen rather than concentrating on what has happened. If you have a different perspective then you are welcome to it.



This has been ask before - and someone posted a list of incompatible formats. Quite long in opposite to the compatible formats...

If you reread the comment you will note that is was directled to a specific individual in order to determine his specific problem, You, on the other hand, are trying to turn the comment into a question and apply it to a general problem for your own purposes.



This argument has been said over and over again: BUT Apple made QT open by offering the extension feature…

Yes, and most people applauded the open nature of this architecture. And, maybe, some day Apple will return to this mode of thinking. Unfortunately, if you continue to live in the past rather than the present, you are likely to ignore most, if not all, of the possible solutions/workarounds. IMHO, people with closed minds are seldom ever satisfied.



As who decides? Apple? If you ask people for making a list of compression formats, would you please make a list for us which codecs are modern and why? For the next 2 years, please. May be I convert all my movies as Apple likes now - and then in 2 years there is a new - more modern codec - and Apple does not like it.


In the past, QT was extendible. But now it is Apple who decides - this is the point for me.

Duh! Apple is performing the the research and development. Apple is doing the programming. Of couse it is making these decisions. Compression formats are normally considered modern if they are highly scaleable (have data rates that can be used for multiple purposes from cell phone use to 2- or 4-K optical media use and everything in between), support anamorphic encoding strategies without patches, and are compatible with modern containers which also do not require patches for proper use. They do not generally include codecs developed two decades ago to target a specic or limited use which may or may not have been abandoned by their originator and are unsupported at the current time.


As to Apple developing or switching to a newr technology in the future, that may very well be. However, It is more likely that such a change would be a minumum of 6 to 10 years away and assumes that current modern formats cannot inclucle addition profiles and/or levels which include features required to support whatever tecnological advance you envision. But what of it. Apple mobile devices originally only supported MPEG-4/H.264 video at 320x240 resolutions. The same codecs now support 2-K content using higher profiles and levels with added encoding features. Therefore, it is currently just as reasonable to expect that such codecs will continue in use much longer than you hypothesize as it is to say they will change based on the generality that technology is constantly evolving.



I am surprised: MPEG-1 is not supported anymore? I can still play it with QuickTime 32 bit and the installed extensions.

And I am surprised that you are not familiar with the MPEG-1 encoder that used to be installed by Toast that was compatible with QT Pro just as Apple's FCP used to install a QT Pro compatible MPEG-2 encoder. Either your youth or your lack of experience is showing.



Yes, indeed. Be prepared that Apple will close doors. As I said: join it & like it - or leave it.

That is one way of putting it. Another is that those of use who adopted MPEG-4/MPEG-4 AVC as our defualt distributopn compression format 8 years ago don't seem compelled to do either.


User uploaded file

Again some of you people don't get it.


I had a perfectly working computer.


my peripherals printer HP office jet and external western digital 6tb raid hard drive.


Itunes with 5 apple tv units doted around the house.


After I "upgraded to mavericks" my external HD stopped working and the data was wiped out...


Why? Because mavericks destroys the raid controller on western digital and lacie drives..Don't take my word for it look at the forums....

Western digital are compensating me very niclely.....But i've still lost the data..


The office jet can no longer scan because of a problem with mavericks, don't take my word for it read the forums.


As for the nature of this thread.......quick time 7 did not work for me and adding perian did nothing.

Something has happened to my files. Basically the files are there but are not opening. For a second the converting box appears then it stops and takes me to the QT info page. With QT 7 it just states that the file cannot be opened same with perian...

If you cannot use QuickTime 7 to play AVI movies, you can only turn to some other software to convert AVI to MOV. After all, AVI can be encoded with different codec and not all codec are supported by Perian.

Again some of you people don't get it.


I had a perfectly working computer.


my peripherals printer HP office jet and external western digital 6tb raid hard drive.


Itunes with 5 apple tv units doted around the house.


After I "upgraded to mavericks" my external HD stopped working and the data was wiped out...


Why? Because mavericks destroys the raid controller on western digital and lacie drives..Don't take my word for it look at the forums....

Western digital are compensating me very niclely.....But i've still lost the data..


The office jet can no longer scan because of a problem with mavericks, don't take my word for it read the forums.


As for the nature of this thread.......quick time 7 did not work for me and adding perian did nothing.

Something has happened to my files. Basically the files are there but are not opening. For a second the converting box appears then it stops and takes me to the QT info page. With QT 7 it just states that the file cannot be opened same with perian...

I suspect very vew people would "get it" when you completely change the topic as you have done by moving from AVI conversions to raid controller destruction and the loss of data. I hope you have been providing feedback to Apple to include specific drive and model information for hardware and contoller software. In fact, you might want to consider opening your own discussion for this topic. Unfortunately, this appears, to some extent, to be the luck of the draw in your choice of harware/software.


For instance, in researching the problem, I see the Pegasis Technology R-4 may be affected but my R-6 is not listed as a problem raid. And, while numerous WD procuts seem to have problems, none of the WD drives used in my Drobo Pro and Drobo 5D remain functional. In addition, my CalDigit raid is also uneffexted nor has my HP Envy stopped printing or scanning. Thus, it appears the problems you have are not generic to Mavericks al 00004000 one but Mavericks in conjuction with certain devices using specific controller software. This is a potentially serious matter which needs to be addressed as soon as possible. The more feedback sent the more resources Apple is likely to devote to the matter.


User uploaded file

AppGeeker video converter is a tool I use that converts videos to just about anything else on my iMac. I do a lot of WMV to MP4 and use it all the time. If I recall correctly it does handle AVI as well.


See: How to Convert AVI to MOV (or MOV to AVI) on Mac/ Windows


This software is extremely easy to use and will help you do some simple editing for AVI if need.

I have a Pentax K5 (about 3 years old) that records in the .AVI what ever (format?, container?) and under Mavericks I can see them in quick look and they will open in iMovie 9.09 but not in in the latest version of iMovie. the are (I think?) 1920*1080 with 16:9 aspect ratio at 25 fps.


Is there any way to convert them that keeps the high deffintion format?

Nevermind I found one.

I have a Pentax K5 (about 3 years old) that records in the .AVI what ever (format?, container?) and under Mavericks I can see them in quick look and they will open in iMovie 9.09 but not in in the latest version of iMovie. the are (I think?) 1920*1080 with 16:9 aspect ratio at 25 fps.


Is there any way to convert them that keeps the high deffintion format?

Your AVI files are probably encoded as Motion JPEG video with PCM (WAV, AIFF, Little Endian Integer, Big Endian Integer, etc.) audio which remins QT X, QT 7, and QL compatible even under Mavericks. Since these are legacy compression formats, they are still "passively" supported by both the AVFoundation and the 32-bit QT embedded structures and need not be "converted" (transcoded to other compression formats) to get them into an MOV file container. Both QT 7 and the free MPEG Streamclip app can copy your AVI compressed data directly to an MOV file container without modifying display dimensions, aspect ratio, or the frame rate. (I.e., the data is not modified in any respect which also means there is no degredation to video quality as can often be the case when transcoding or exporting the content to different compression formats.)



Nevermind I found one.

If you are using an app to actually "convert" your AVI files to other compression formats, you may wish to try the data copy workflow mentioned above to see which workflow you prefer.


User uploaded file

Tried installing an older version of Quicktime 10.0 but the new OS Maverick rejected it. Guess will need to switch player to either Divx or VLC.


<Edited By Host>

Tried installing an older version of Quicktime 10.0 but the new OS Maverick rejected it. Guess will need to switch player to either Divx or VLC.

Each Mac OS X version (Snow Leopard, Lion, Mountain Lion, and Mavericks) has a different version of embedded QT X suport structure and each embedded support structure only supports the specific apps which are compatible with that Mac OS system. (E.g., the QT X Player v10.0 is only conpatible with the structure embedded in Mac OS X v10.6 Snow Leopard.)


User uploaded file

What do you mean with "an older version of QuickTime 10"? http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3678 might help...

I used also QuickTime 7, but for me, it's not very... beautiful...

Why QuickTime Won't Play AVI Files?


AVI (Audio Video Interleaved) is a container format designed by Microsoft to wrap audio and video stream together. The video in AVI file can be compressed by many kinds of codec, such as MJPEG (Motion JPEG), MPEG-1, MPEG-2, DivX, XviD, WMV and others. To play all AVI files, your player must support all of these codecs. So far, no matter you are a Windows user or a Mac user, QuickTime only natively plays AVI files with MJPEG video.


As a great open-source QuickTime component, Perian is the saver to allow QuickTime to play all kinds of AVI videos for Mac users. Unfortunately, the latest version 1.2.3 of Perian is not compatible with Mac OS X Mavericks (10.9), Mountain Lion (10.8) and Lion (10.7).


In order to solve "QuickTime won't play AVI" on Mac (Mavericks included) and Windows, it is best to convert AVI to QuickTime more popular formats like MP4, MOV.

Converting everything isn't really a friendly or viable solution for many as some people may have a LOT of files and every single time you convert a compressed format to another format you LOSE QUALITY. Thus, it's usually BEST to use a viewer that can play the format natively. Something like VLC or XBMC (now called "Kodi") can play most formats natively and thus lose no quality and requir 00004000 e no conversion effort on the user's part.


What is lost by Perian abandoning the Mac community combined with Apple changing Quicktime to not support the same plugins is the ability to view these files using Quicklook (where you press the spacebar to preview the file in the Finder). It would have been nice if someone would have offered to pick up supporting Perian where the developers left off, but it might be technically impossible to support Quicklook at this point without Apple's help if they changed the plugin formats for Quicktime to either not exist or are different. Either way losing Quicklook support in OS X for all formats has been one of the biggest steps BACKWARDS for OS X in its entire history. It's a shame Apple can't recognize the fact that there are other formats out there besides the ones Apple supports. Some of us need to exist in a larger world than just Apple. Sadly, Apple has always done what it wants rather than what its users need.

If your AVI is encoded with Motion JPEG (M-JPEG), you can use QuickTime to convert AVI to MOV.


If your AVI is encoded with other codec, you may try QuickTime Pro or a third party to convert AVI to MOV on Mac or Windows

If your AVI is encoded with Motion JPEG (M-JPEG), you can use QuickTime to convert AVI to MOV.


If your AVI is encoded with other codec, you may try QuickTime Pro or a third party to convert AVI to MOV

The video in AVI file can be compressed by many kinds of codec, such as MJPEG (Motion JPEG), MPEG-1, MPEG-2, DivX, XviD, WMV and others. QuickTime only natively plays AVI files with MJPEG video. To solve this issue, you can turn to AVI to QuickTime MOV Converter. You can also refer to a full guide on .avi to .mov conversion.

Mac Video Converter is quite useful. It supports avi files in different codec. You can easily convert .avi to .quicktime mov in just three steps.

Thank you, Livebox! I did not know about the 'Encode Selected Video Files' utility. This will save me lots of time converting individual files in QTP. Much appreciated!